Coyle Michael A, Keenan Desmond B, Henderson Linda S, Watkins Michael L, Haumann Brett K, Mayleben David W, Wilson Michael G
Physiology Program, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA.
Cough. 2005 Aug 4;1:3. doi: 10.1186/1745-9974-1-3.
To date, methods used to assess cough have been primarily subjective, and only broadly reflect the impact of chronic cough and/or chronic cough therapies on quality of life. Objective assessment of cough has been attempted, but early techniques were neither ambulatory nor feasible for long-term data collection. We evaluated a novel ambulatory cardio-respiratory monitoring system with an integrated unidirectional, contact microphone, and report here the results from a study of patients with COPD who were videotaped in a quasi-controlled environment for 24 continuous hours while wearing the ambulatory system.
Eight patients with a documented history of COPD with ten or more years of smoking (6 women; age 57.4 +/- 11.8 yrs.; percent predicted FEV1 49.6 +/- 13.7%) who complained of cough were evaluated in a clinical research unit equipped with video and sound recording capabilities. All patients wore the LifeShirt system (LS) while undergoing simultaneous video (with sound) surveillance. Video data were visually inspected and annotated to indicate all cough events. Raw physiologic data records were visually inspected by technicians who remained blinded to the video data. Cough events from LS were analyzed quantitatively with a specialized software algorithm to identify cough. The output of the software algorithm was compared to video records on a per event basis in order to determine the validity of the LS system to detect cough in COPD patients.
Video surveillance identified a total of 3,645 coughs, while LS identified 3,363 coughs during the same period. The median cough rate per patient was 21.3 coughs.hr-1 (Range: 10.1 cghs.hr(-1) - 59.9 cghs.hr(-1)). The overall accuracy of the LS system was 99.0%. Overall sensitivity and specificity of LS, when compared to video surveillance, were 0.781 and 0.996, respectively, while positive- and negative-predictive values were 0.846 and 0.994. There was very good agreement between the LS system and video (kappa = 0.807).
The LS system demonstrated a high level of accuracy and agreement when compared to video surveillance for the measurement of cough in patients with COPD.
迄今为止,用于评估咳嗽的方法主要是主观的,仅能大致反映慢性咳嗽和/或慢性咳嗽治疗对生活质量的影响。人们曾尝试对咳嗽进行客观评估,但早期技术既无法实现动态监测,也不适用于长期数据收集。我们评估了一种新型的动态心肺监测系统,该系统集成了单向接触式麦克风,在此报告一项针对慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)患者的研究结果,这些患者在佩戴该动态监测系统的情况下,于准对照环境中连续24小时被录像。
在一个具备视频和声音录制功能的临床研究单元中,对8名有记录的COPD病史且有十年或更长时间吸烟史的患者(6名女性;年龄57.4±11.8岁;预测FEV1百分比为49.6±13.7%)进行评估,这些患者均主诉咳嗽。所有患者在接受同步视频(带声音)监测时均佩戴LifeShirt系统(LS)。对视频数据进行目视检查并标注,以指示所有咳嗽事件。技术人员对原始生理数据记录进行目视检查,这些技术人员对视频数据不知情。使用专门的软件算法对LS记录的咳嗽事件进行定量分析以识别咳嗽。将软件算法的输出结果与每个事件的视频记录进行逐一比较,以确定LS系统在检测COPD患者咳嗽方面的有效性。
视频监测共识别出3645次咳嗽,而同期LS识别出3363次咳嗽。每位患者的咳嗽率中位数为21.3次/小时(范围:10.1次/小时 - 59.9次/小时)。LS系统的总体准确率为99.0%。与视频监测相比,LS的总体敏感性和特异性分别为0.781和0.996,而阳性预测值和阴性预测值分别为0.846和0.994。LS系统与视频之间具有非常好的一致性(kappa = 0.807)。
与视频监测相比,LS系统在测量COPD患者咳嗽方面显示出高度的准确性和一致性。