Costantini Massimo, Beccaro Monica, Merlo Franco
Unit of Clinical Epidemiology, National Cancer Institute, Genova, Italy.
Palliat Med. 2005 Dec;19(8):628-38. doi: 10.1191/0269216305pm1086oa.
The Italian Survey of the Dying of Cancer (ISDOC) was undertaken to evaluate the experiences of Italian people dying from cancer during their last three months of life in all settings of care.
A two-stage probability sample was used to estimate end-of-life outcomes of about 160 000 Italian cancer deaths. In the first stage, 30 of the 197 Italian Local Health Districts (LHD) were randomly selected after stratification. In the second stage, a fixed proportion of cancer deaths was randomly drawn from each LHD, and 2000 death certificates of patients who died of cancer were identified. The non-professional caregivers were identified and interviewed using a semi-structured questionnaire derived from the Views of Informal Carers--Evaluation of Services (VOICES).
Caregivers were successfully identified for 95% of the sample (n=1900). The caregiver was the child (42.7%), the spouse (36.5%), another family member (17.3%), or a friend (1.5%). Only 3% of the sample had no non-professional support. An interview was obtained for 1289 (64.5%) of the sample, at a median time of 234 days after death (range: 103-374). Higher response rates were associated with home death (67.7%) and with a higher education (>70%). Conversely, a lower response rate was observed when the caregiver was the spouse (56.2%). Response rates ranged from about 80% for letters sent four to six months after the patients' death to about 60% for letters sent after eight months or more. A descriptive analysis of refusals, based on the transcripts of the telephone calls, allowed classification of 61% of refusals for at least one of the two dimensions examined: caregiver psychological suffering and quality of care received by the patient. Psychological suffering was present in 99% of refusals examined for this dimension (48%). Conversely, a poor quality of care was reported by 63% of the refusals examined for this dimension (23%).
The ISDOC survey provides a representative picture of the needs and problems associated with the last three months of life of Italian cancer patients.
开展意大利癌症患者临终情况调查(ISDOC),以评估意大利癌症患者在其生命最后三个月内在所有护理环境中的经历。
采用两阶段概率抽样来估计约16万例意大利癌症死亡患者的临终结局。在第一阶段,对197个意大利地方卫生区(LHD)中的30个进行分层后随机抽取。在第二阶段,从每个LHD中随机抽取固定比例的癌症死亡病例,识别出2000例癌症死亡患者的死亡证明。使用源自非正式护理人员观点——服务评估(VOICES)的半结构化问卷识别并访谈非专业护理人员。
95%的样本(n = 1900)成功识别出护理人员。护理人员为子女(42.7%)、配偶(36.5%)、其他家庭成员(17.3%)或朋友(1.5%)。只有3%的样本没有非专业支持。对样本中的1289例(64.5%)进行了访谈,访谈时间中位数为死亡后234天(范围:103 - 374天)。较高的回应率与在家中死亡(67.7%)和较高的教育程度(>70%)相关。相反,当护理人员为配偶时,回应率较低(56.2%)。回应率范围从患者死亡后4至6个月发出信件的约80%到8个月或更长时间后发出信件的约60%。基于电话记录对拒绝情况进行描述性分析,在检查的两个维度(护理人员心理痛苦和患者接受的护理质量)中,至少有一个维度可对61%的拒绝情况进行分类。在检查此维度的拒绝情况中,99%(48%)存在心理痛苦。相反,在检查此维度的拒绝情况中,63%(23%)报告护理质量差。
ISDOC调查提供了与意大利癌症患者生命最后三个月相关的需求和问题的代表性情况。