Pfaeffle H James, Stabile Kathryne J, Li Zong-Ming, Tomaino Matthew M
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, PA, USA.
J Hand Surg Am. 2006 Feb;31(2):269-78. doi: 10.1016/j.jhsa.2005.09.022.
Longitudinal radioulnar dissociation may result when a compressive load to the hand results in excessive proximal migration of the radius with interosseous ligament (IOL) disruption and radial head fracture. Interosseous ligament reconstruction has been proposed to restore more normal forearm mechanics. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of IOL reconstruction on compressive load transfer through the forearm after excision and metallic replacement of the radial head in cadavers.
In 8 cadaveric forearms, 138 N of compressive load was applied to the hand in neutral forearm rotation and neutral elbow varus-valgus alignment. We measured proximal radial migration and 3-dimensional force vectors acting on the distal radius, distal ulna, IOL, proximal radius, and proximal ulna. The experiment was repeated in order for 5 conditions: (1) with the IOL intact, (2) with the IOL reconstructed with a double-bundle flexor carpi radialis construct, (3) with the radial head excised, (4) after metallic radial head arthroplasty, and (5) after cutting the IOL reconstruction. Analysis of variance was used for statistical comparisons.
With the IOL intact the resultant load in the distal radius was 94% +/- 3% of hand load, with 75% +/- 2% transmitted to the proximal radius. Double-bundle flexor carpi radialis reconstruction effectively restored this relationship. After radial head excision the resultant distal radius load decreased whereas great increases were seen in the resultant distal ulna load, the resultant load in the IOL reconstruction, the resultant load in the proximal ulna, and proximal radial migration. Force continued to transfer through the proximal radius transversely, with a 400% increase in transverse force, a consequence of abutment of the radial stump caused by proximal radioulnar convergence (there was no contact at the capitellum). After radial head arthroplasty loads transferred across the wrist remained closer to intact but the resultant load on the distal ulna and proximal radius remained increased. With cutting of the IOL reconstruction transverse forces in the forearm became negligible, the resultant distal ulna load increased by 50%, and the resultant radial head load increased by 25%. Proximal migration of the radius was small and was increased by 4.6 mm with radial head excision and by 1 mm after radial head replacement compared with the IOL-reconstructed, radial head-intact state.
Interosseous ligament reconstruction may help improve treatment of longitudinal radioulnar dissociation but remains an experimental procedure.
当手部受到压缩负荷导致桡骨过度向近端移位,伴有骨间韧带(IOL)断裂和桡骨头骨折时,可能会发生桡尺骨纵向分离。有人提出进行骨间韧带重建以恢复更正常的前臂力学。本研究的目的是评估在尸体上切除桡骨头并进行金属置换后,IOL重建对通过前臂的压缩负荷传递的影响。
在8具尸体前臂中,在前臂中立旋转和肘关节中立内翻-外翻对线的情况下,对手部施加138 N的压缩负荷。我们测量了桡骨近端移位以及作用于桡骨远端、尺骨远端、IOL、桡骨近端和尺骨近端的三维力矢量。为了模拟5种情况重复进行该实验:(1)IOL完整;(2)用双束桡侧腕屈肌结构重建IOL;(3)切除桡骨头;(4)进行金属桡骨头置换术后;(5)切断IOL重建后。采用方差分析进行统计学比较。
IOL完整时,桡骨远端的合力负荷为手部负荷的94%±3%,其中75%±2%传递至桡骨近端。双束桡侧腕屈肌重建有效地恢复了这种关系。切除桡骨头后,桡骨远端的合力负荷降低,而尺骨远端的合力负荷、IOL重建处的合力负荷、尺骨近端的合力负荷以及桡骨近端移位均显著增加。力继续通过桡骨近端横向传递,横向力增加了400%,这是桡尺骨近端汇聚导致桡骨残端对接的结果(在肱骨小头处无接触)。桡骨头置换术后,通过腕部传递的负荷仍更接近完整状态,但尺骨远端和桡骨近端的合力负荷仍增加。切断IOL重建后,前臂的横向力变得可以忽略不计,尺骨远端的合力负荷增加了50%,桡骨头的合力负荷增加了25%。与IOL重建、桡骨头完整的状态相比,桡骨近端移位较小,切除桡骨头后增加了4.6 mm,桡骨头置换后增加了1 mm。
骨间韧带重建可能有助于改善桡尺骨纵向分离的治疗,但仍是一种实验性手术。