Ylioja Shelley, Carlson Synnöve, Raij Tuukka T, Pertovaara Antti
Institute of Biomedicine/Physiology, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
Pain. 2006 Mar;121(1-2):6-13. doi: 10.1016/j.pain.2005.11.014. Epub 2006 Feb 9.
We studied the influence of temporal parameters on localization of monofilament-evoked touch versus thulium laser-induced and C fiber-mediated pain in human subjects. Stimuli were applied at interstimulus intervals (ISIs) varying from 1 to 9 s to determine discrimination between successive stimulus sites in the palmar skin. Localization threshold was about two times higher for heat pain than touch. The localization threshold for pain, but not touch, decreased with prolongation of the ISI from 1 to 7-9 s, and it remained higher for pain even at the ISI of 9 s. The response time was longer for pain than touch, and it increased with an increase in the ISI, independent of the modality. Discriminative capacity, as assessed by the receiver operating characteristics curve, was markedly better for touch than pain. The discriminative capacity decreased with an increase of the ISI, but only for touch. The results indicate that localization is more accurate for touch than pain. Temporal summation of C fiber-evoked pain contributes to the reduced accuracy of pain localization if the ISI is < or = 3 s. Additionally, temporal factors dissociatively influence the response strategy in the tactile versus pain localization task with the prolongation of the ISI from 1 to 9 s. Due to this strategy change, localization threshold for touch remains constant at prolonged ISIs, in spite of a decrease in discriminative capacity. In a cutaneous localization task, the subject's accuracy and response strategy vary with the modality and temporal parameters of sequential test stimulation.
我们研究了时间参数对人类受试者中,单丝诱发触觉与铥激光诱发及C纤维介导疼痛定位的影响。刺激以1至9秒不等的刺激间隔(ISI)施加,以确定手掌皮肤中连续刺激部位之间的辨别能力。热痛的定位阈值比触觉高约两倍。疼痛的定位阈值(而非触觉的定位阈值)随着ISI从1秒延长至7 - 9秒而降低,即使在ISI为9秒时,疼痛的定位阈值仍更高。疼痛的反应时间比触觉长,且随着ISI的增加而增加,与刺激模式无关。通过接受者操作特征曲线评估的辨别能力,触觉明显优于疼痛。辨别能力随着ISI的增加而降低,但仅针对触觉。结果表明,触觉的定位比疼痛更准确。如果ISI小于或等于3秒,C纤维诱发疼痛的时间总和会导致疼痛定位准确性降低。此外,随着ISI从1秒延长至9秒,时间因素在触觉与疼痛定位任务中对反应策略产生解离性影响。由于这种策略变化,尽管辨别能力下降,但在延长的ISI下,触觉的定位阈值保持不变。在皮肤定位任务中,受试者的准确性和反应策略会随着连续测试刺激的模式和时间参数而变化。