Balain Birender, Eisenstein S M, Alo G O, Darby Alan J, Cassar-Pullicino V N, Roberts S E, Jaffray D C
Robert Jones & Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic Hospital, Oswestry, United Kingdom.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2006 Jun 1;31(13):E414-20. doi: 10.1097/01.brs.0000219867.07683.7a.
This is a case series in which case notes review and telephone interview update were used to assess the outcome following coccygectomy.
To correlate the clinical results of coccygectomy with histology and discography of the sacrococcygeal and intercoccygeal segments.
Clinicians regard chronic disabling pain in the sacrococcygeal region with much dismay because of the reputed unpredictability of the treatment outcome.
A total of 38 patients had coccygectomy for intractable coccydynia, and 31 were available for follow-up. The excised specimen with intact sacrococcygeal joint was sent for histologic examination in 22 patients. There were 6 patients investigated using sacrococcygeal and intercoccygeal discography.
Mean postoperative follow-up was 6.75 years (range 2-16). There were 16 patients who benefited highly from the surgery, and 6 benefited to some extent, giving an overall beneficial result of 71%. Of all specimens, 86.3% had histologic changes of degeneration. Moderate-to-severe degenerate changes in sacrococcygeal and intercoccygeal joints on histology were found in 54.5% of patients. Of these patients, 83.3% did well with surgery. Only 57.1% of those patients with mild changes did well. There were 2 patients who had positive discography, and both did well with surgery. Three patients had negative diskographies, and 2 of them had a poor result, and 1 had only some relief.
It is possible that degenerate changes in sacrococcygeal discs and/or intercoccygeal discs are associated with pain. Surgical results are better in those with a severe degree of degenerative change. Coccygectomy remains a successful treatment for a majority of severely disabled patients with coccydynia.
这是一个病例系列研究,通过病例记录回顾和电话随访更新来评估尾骨切除术后的结果。
将尾骨切除术的临床结果与骶尾段和尾骨间段的组织学及椎间盘造影结果相关联。
由于治疗结果的不可预测性,临床医生对骶尾区域的慢性致残性疼痛深感沮丧。
共有38例患者因顽固性尾骨痛接受了尾骨切除术,其中31例可供随访。22例患者将完整的骶尾关节切除标本送去做组织学检查。6例患者接受了骶尾段和尾骨间段的椎间盘造影检查。
术后平均随访6.75年(范围2 - 16年)。16例患者从手术中获益极大,6例患者有一定程度的获益,总体有效率为71%。在所有标本中,86.3%有退变的组织学改变。54.5%的患者在组织学上骶尾关节和尾骨间关节有中度至重度退变改变。在这些患者中,83.3%手术效果良好。轻度改变的患者中只有57.1%手术效果良好。2例椎间盘造影阳性的患者手术效果均良好。3例椎间盘造影阴性的患者中,2例效果差,1例仅有部分缓解。
骶尾椎间盘和/或尾骨间椎间盘的退变改变可能与疼痛有关。退变程度严重的患者手术效果更好。对于大多数严重残疾的尾骨痛患者,尾骨切除术仍是一种成功的治疗方法。