Haney Elizabeth M, Nicolaidis Christina, Hunter Alan, Chan Benjamin K S, Cooney Thomas G, Bowen Judith L
Department of Medicine, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR, USA.
BMC Med Educ. 2006 Jul 6;6:35. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-6-35.
Despite recent residency workload and hour limitations, little research on the relationship between workload and learning has been done. We sought to define residents' perceptions of the optimal patient workload for learning, and to determine how certain variables contribute to those perceptions. Our hypothesis was that the relationship between perceived workload and learning has a maximum point (forming a parabolic curve): that either too many or too few patients results in sub-optimal learning.
Residents on inpatient services at two academic teaching hospitals reported their team and individual patient censuses, and rated their perception of their learning; the patient acuity; case variety; and how challenged they felt. To estimate maximum learning scores, linear regression models with quadratic terms were fit on learning score.
Resident self-perceived learning correlated with higher acuity and greater heterogeneity of case variety. The equation of census versus learning score, adjusted for perception of acuity and case mix scores, showed a parabolic curve in some cases but not in others.
These data suggest that perceived resident workload is complex, and impacted by additional variables including patient acuity and heterogeneity of case variety. Parabolic curves exist for interns with regard to overall census and for senior residents with regard to new admissions on long call days.
尽管近期对住院医师工作量和工作时长有所限制,但关于工作量与学习之间关系的研究仍较少。我们试图明确住院医师对学习的最佳患者工作量的看法,并确定某些变量如何影响这些看法。我们的假设是,感知到的工作量与学习之间的关系存在一个最大值点(形成一条抛物线):即患者过多或过少都会导致学习效果欠佳。
两所学术教学医院的住院部住院医师报告了其团队及个人负责的患者数量,并对自己的学习感受、患者病情严重程度、病例种类以及自身所感受到的挑战程度进行评分。为了估计最大学习分数,我们对学习分数拟合了带有二次项的线性回归模型。
住院医师的自我感知学习与更高的病情严重程度以及更大的病例种类异质性相关。在对病情严重程度感知和病例组合分数进行校正后,患者数量与学习分数之间的方程在某些情况下呈现出抛物线,但在其他情况下并非如此。
这些数据表明,住院医师感知到的工作量很复杂,并且会受到包括患者病情严重程度和病例种类异质性等其他变量的影响。对于实习医生而言,总体患者数量方面存在抛物线关系;对于高年资住院医师而言,在长时间值班日新收患者数量方面存在抛物线关系。