Kuther Tara L, Posada Margarita
Western Connecticut State University, USA.
Adv Psychol Res. 2004;32:163-73.
Researchers who work with children and adolescents are confronted with a special set of ethical issues regarding informed consent. Federal guidelines generally stipulate that minors cannot provide informed consent for participation in research. Instead parental or guardian permission must be obtained for a minor to participate in research. However the literature in developmental psychology has shown that adolescents are able to make meaningful decisions and advocates for youth have argued that researchers must respect the autonomy rights of children and adolescents. The present review examines the developmental literature on children and adolescents' capacities to make informed, voluntary, and rational decisions to participate in research. The purposes and benefits of assent are identified. Recommendations are offered on how to enhance and respect minors' developing autonomy while protecting them from risks of research.
从事儿童和青少年研究工作的人员面临着一系列与知情同意相关的特殊伦理问题。联邦指导方针通常规定,未成年人不能为参与研究提供知情同意。相反,必须获得父母或监护人的许可,未成年人才能够参与研究。然而,发展心理学的文献表明,青少年能够做出有意义的决定,并且青少年权益倡导者认为,研究人员必须尊重儿童和青少年的自主权利。本综述考察了关于儿童和青少年做出参与研究的知情、自愿和理性决定的能力的发展文献。确定了赞同的目的和益处。就如何在保护未成年人免受研究风险的同时增强并尊重他们不断发展的自主性提出了建议。