Evans Jacquelyn R, Lou Short Billie, Van Meurs Krisa, Cheryl Sachs Hari
Division of Neonatology, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104, USA.
Clin Ther. 2006 Sep;28(9):1366-84. doi: 10.1016/j.clinthera.2006.09.006.
Despite increasing investigation in the area of cardiovascular instability in preterm infants, huge gaps in knowledge remain. None of the current treatments for hypotension, including the use of inotropic agents, have been well studied in the preterm population, and data regarding safety and efficacy are lacking. Thus, the labeling information regarding the use of inotropes as therapeutic agents in this population is inadequate.
This article reviews the current deficiencies in knowledge with respect to measuring and achieving normal organ perfusion; summarizes the clinical, methodological, and ethical issues to consider when designing trials to evaluate medications for hemodynamic instability in the preterm neonate; and proposes 2 possible trial designs. Unanswered questions and potential obstacles for the systematic study of drugs to treat cardiovascular instability in preterm neonates are discussed.
The neonatal Cardiology Group was established in 2003 by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD) as part of the Newborn Drug Development Initiative. The Cardiology Group conducted a number of teleconferences and one meeting to develop a document addressing gaps in knowledge regarding cardiovascular drugs commonly used in low-birth-weight neonates and possible approaches to investigate these drugs. This work was presented at a workshop cosponsored by the NICHD and the FDA held in March 2004 in Baltimore, Maryland. Information for this article was gathered during this initiative.
To develop rational, evidence-based guidelines corroborated by robust scientific data for cardiovascular support in newborns, well-designed and adequately powered pharmacologic studies and clinical trials are needed to evaluate the safety and efficacy of inotropic agents and to determine the short- and long-term effects of these drugs. Trials investigating the currently available and novel therapies for cardiovascular instability in neonates will provide information that can be incorporated into product labeling and a scientific framework for cardiovascular management in critically ill neonates. The Cardiology Group identified and prioritized 2 conditions for investigation of therapeutic options for the management of neonatal cardiovascular instability: (1) cardiovascular instability in preterm neonates; and (2) cardiac dysfunction in neonates after cardiopulmonary bypass surgery. Key research questions in the area of cardiovascular instability in the preterm infant include determining optimal blood pressure (BP) in preterm infants; identifying better measures than BP to determine organ perfusion; optimizing hemodynamic treatments; and clarifying any associations between BP or therapy for low BP and mortality, intraventricular hemorrhage, periventricular leukomalacia, necrotizing enterocolitis, retinopathy of prematurity, and neurodevelopmental outcome. The Cardiology Group concluded that the study of inotropic agents in neonates using outcomes of importance to patients will require a complicated trial design to address the elements discussed. The group proposed 2 clinical trial designs: (1) a placebo-controlled trial with rescue therapy for symptomatic infants; and (2) a targeted BP trial.
This summary is intended to stimulate and assist future research in the area of cardiovascular support for preterm infants.
尽管对早产儿心血管不稳定领域的研究日益增多,但仍存在巨大的知识空白。目前用于治疗低血压的方法,包括使用强心剂,在早产人群中均未得到充分研究,且缺乏有关安全性和有效性的数据。因此,关于强心剂在该人群中作为治疗药物使用的标签信息并不充分。
本文回顾了在测量和实现正常器官灌注方面目前存在的知识缺陷;总结了在设计评估早产儿血流动力学不稳定药物的试验时需要考虑的临床、方法学和伦理问题;并提出了两种可能的试验设计。讨论了用于治疗早产儿心血管不稳定药物的系统研究中尚未解决的问题和潜在障碍。
新生儿心脏病学小组于2003年由美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)和国家儿童健康与人类发展研究所(NICHD)作为新生儿药物开发倡议的一部分成立。心脏病学小组召开了多次电话会议和一次会议,以制定一份文件,解决低体重新生儿常用心血管药物的知识空白以及研究这些药物的可能方法。这项工作在2004年3月于马里兰州巴尔的摩举行的由NICHD和FDA共同主办的研讨会上进行了展示。本文的信息是在该倡议期间收集的。
为了制定合理的、基于证据的指南,并得到强有力的科学数据支持新生儿心血管支持,需要精心设计且有足够效力的药理学研究和临床试验,以评估强心剂的安全性和有效性,并确定这些药物的短期和长期影响。研究新生儿目前可用和新型心血管不稳定疗法的试验将提供可纳入产品标签的信息以及危重新生儿心血管管理的科学框架。心脏病学小组确定并优先考虑了两个用于研究新生儿心血管不稳定治疗选择的条件:(1)早产儿心血管不稳定;(2)体外循环手术后新生儿的心脏功能障碍。早产儿心血管不稳定领域的关键研究问题包括确定早产儿的最佳血压(BP);确定比血压更好的测量器官灌注的方法;优化血流动力学治疗;以及阐明血压或低血压治疗与死亡率、脑室内出血、脑室周围白质软化、坏死性小肠结肠炎、早产儿视网膜病变和神经发育结局之间的任何关联。心脏病学小组得出结论,使用对患者重要的结局研究新生儿强心剂将需要复杂的试验设计来解决所讨论的要素。该小组提出了两种临床试验设计:(1)对有症状婴儿进行救援治疗的安慰剂对照试验;(2)靶向血压试验。
本综述旨在激发和协助未来在早产儿心血管支持领域的研究。