Takashima Tetsuya, Iwamoto Tomotada
Osaka Prefectural Hospital Organization Osaka Prefectural Medical Center for Respiratory and Allergic Diseases.
Kekkaku. 2006 Nov;81(11):693-707.
Molecular epidemiology of tuberculosis (TB) is a science to study TB transmission dynamics and to enhance our understanding of the epidemiology of TB by utilizing molecular typing methods as an adjunct to classical epidemiological approach. Before the era of molecular epidemiology, it was quite difficult to ascertain the source of the infections since M. tuberculosis is spread by air-borne droplets of respiratory secretions expelled by an infectious person to a susceptible host and it can remain latent as an asymptomatic infection for years. Now a day, our understanding of TB transmission dynamics has been refined by genotyping of M. tuberculosis strains. The methods of molecular epidemiology, especially IS6110 RFLP of M. tuberculosis, were first introduced to outbreak investigations and then gradually been expanded its application to population-based study in Japan. IS6110 RFLP is obviously a powerful tool for strain differentiation of M. tuberculosis but its labor-intensiveness limits the achievable throughput and makes it less useful for long-term prospective studies. Recently, apart from IS6110 RFLP, DNA amplification-based method, i.e., variable number of tandem repeats (VNTR) has appeared as a substitute for or adjunct to the IS6110 RFLP. In this symposium, we have invited four opinion leaders in molecular epidemiology of TB from different fields: Mycobacterium reference center, basic science, clinical practice, and public health practice. We, as the chairpersons of this symposium, hope that this symposium would trigger the development of molecular epidemiological network of TB in Japan. 1. Achievement and problem of molecular epidemiologic study with IS6110-RFLP analyses of tuberculosis in Okinawa: Shinji MAEDA (Mycobacterium Reference Center, The Research Institute of Tuberculosis, Japan Anti-Tuberculosis Association) The long-term RFLP analyses of tuberculosis in Okinawa showed that endemic M. tuberculosis might be present. This is one of the achievements of our project study. On the other hand, for more effective examination of contact persons, information of molecular epidemiology should be used actively. Therefore because the analysis report needs to be sent back quickly, the PCR-based VNTR method should substitute for the RFLP analysis. 2. Basic knowledge and application of Variable Numbers of Tandem Repeats: Kei NISHIMORI (Department of epidemiology, National Institute of Animal Health) Genomic loci of Variable Numbers of Tandem Repeats (VNTR loci) in Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex and Mycobacterium avium, the history of analysis of VNTR loci, the hypothetical mechanisms of increase or decrease of number of repeats, the structures of the loci, and the necessity of standardizing the VNTR typing were introduced. 3. Clinical application of VNTR: Tomoshige MATSUMOTO, and Hiromi ANO (Department of Clinical Research and Development, Osaka Prefectural Hospital Organization Osaka Prefectural Medical Center for Respiratory and Allergic Diseases) Tuberculosis genotyping was first introduced to outbreak investigations and population-based studies. The advent of Variable Numbers of Tandem Repeats (VNTR) can be applied to clinical fields of not only Mycobacterium tuberculosis but also of Mycobacterium avium. In Osaka Prefectural Medical Center for Respiratory and Allergic Diseases, clinical application of VNTR was first introduced in Japan to determine whether Mycobacterium tuberculosis or avium disease was caused by reactivation or reinfection when relapsed. We showed some examples about usefulness of the clinical application of VNTR. 4. Molecular epidemiology of tuberculosis to improve TB prevention and control activities: Tomotada IWAMOTO (Department of microbiology, Kobe Institute of Health), Riyo FUJIYAMA, Noriko TANAKA, Yasuto KAWAKAMI (Kobe City Public Health Center), Chika SHIRAI (Hyogo-ku Health and Welfare Department, Kobe) M. tuberculosis isolates in Kobe have been characterized as: a) Beijing family strains are highly prevalent (77%), b) two major MIRU profiles in Beijing family were found, one is globally pandemic genotype and the other is locally prevalent strains, c) six strains belonged to T3-Osaka family, and d) Manila family strains made cluster consisting of 3 strains. Kobe VNTR Database which consists of 12-loci MIRU and 9 additional VNTR loci has been developed. The basis for the selection of these supplemental 9 VNTR loci and the application of VNTR database in TB control program were introduced.
结核病的分子流行病学是一门通过利用分子分型方法作为经典流行病学方法的辅助手段,来研究结核病传播动态并增进我们对结核病流行病学理解的科学。在分子流行病学时代之前,由于结核分枝杆菌通过感染者呼吸道分泌物的飞沫传播给易感宿主,并且它可以多年以无症状感染的形式潜伏,因此很难确定感染源。如今,我们对结核病传播动态的理解通过结核分枝杆菌菌株的基因分型得到了完善。分子流行病学方法,特别是结核分枝杆菌的IS6110限制性片段长度多态性分析(RFLP),首先被引入到疫情调查中,然后在日本逐渐扩大其在基于人群研究中的应用。IS6110 RFLP显然是区分结核分枝杆菌菌株的有力工具,但其劳动强度大,限制了可实现的通量,并且对于长期前瞻性研究不太有用。最近,除了IS6110 RFLP之外,基于DNA扩增的方法,即可变数目串联重复序列(VNTR),已作为IS6110 RFLP的替代或辅助方法出现。在本次研讨会上,我们邀请了来自不同领域的四位结核病分子流行病学的意见领袖:分枝杆菌参考中心、基础科学、临床实践和公共卫生实践领域。作为本次研讨会的主席,我们希望本次研讨会能够推动日本结核病分子流行病学网络的发展。1. 冲绳地区结核病IS6110-RFLP分析的分子流行病学研究的成果与问题:前田真司(日本抗结核协会结核病研究所分枝杆菌参考中心)冲绳地区结核病的长期RFLP分析表明,可能存在地方性结核分枝杆菌。这是我们项目研究的成果之一。另一方面,为了更有效地检查接触者,应积极利用分子流行病学信息。因此,由于分析报告需要快速反馈,基于PCR的VNTR方法应替代RFLP分析。2. 可变数目串联重复序列的基础知识与应用:西森圭(国立动物卫生研究所流行病学部)介绍了结核分枝杆菌复合群和鸟分枝杆菌中可变数目串联重复序列(VNTR位点)的基因组位点、VNTR位点的分析历史、重复序列数目增加或减少的假设机制、位点的结构以及VNTR分型标准化的必要性。3. VNTR的临床应用:松本智重、阿野宏美(大阪府立医院组织大阪府呼吸与过敏性疾病医学中心临床研究与开发部)结核病基因分型首先被引入到疫情调查和基于人群的研究中。可变数目串联重复序列(VNTR)的出现不仅可以应用于结核分枝杆菌的临床领域,也可以应用于鸟分枝杆菌的临床领域。在大阪府呼吸与过敏性疾病医学中心,VNTR的临床应用在日本首次被引入,以确定结核分枝杆菌或鸟分枝杆菌疾病复发时是由再激活还是再感染引起的。我们展示了一些VNTR临床应用的有用实例。4. 结核病分子流行病学以改善结核病预防和控制活动:岩本智忠(神户健康研究所微生物学部)、藤山理代、田中典子、川上靖人(神户市公共卫生中心)、白井千佳(神户市兵库区健康与福利部)神户的结核分枝杆菌分离株具有以下特征:a)北京家族菌株高度流行(77%),b)在北京家族中发现了两种主要的MIRU图谱,一种是全球大流行基因型,另一种是本地流行菌株,c)六株属于T3-大阪家族,d)马尼拉家族菌株形成了由三株组成的簇。已经建立了由12个位点的MIRU和9个额外VNTR位点组成的神户VNTR数据库。介绍了选择这9个补充VNTR位点的依据以及VNTR数据库在结核病控制项目中的应用。