Simic M, Tasic M
Institute of Legal Medicine, School of Medicine Novi Sad, H. Veljka 5, 21000 Novi Sad, Serbia.
Forensic Sci Int. 2007 Oct 2;172(1):28-32. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2006.11.008. Epub 2006 Dec 29.
In the period 1991-2005, a blood-alcohol concentration (BAC) analysis was carried out at the Institute of forensic medicine in Novi Sad including 2023 two consecutive blood specimens using the Headspace Gas Chromatography method. Cases with no alcohol concentration values, as well as cases where blood samples were taken within 1 h after the criminal act, were not taken into consideration. Following this rule, 1198 cases were considered in this study and all samples were grouped in 29 ranges of BAC1 of delta(BAC) = 0.1 g/kg, starting from 0.1-0.19 g/kg to 2.9-2.99 g/kg of absolute alcohol. Gathered results and elimination curve differ from the zero-order model of elimination proposed by Widmark and point to an elimination process similar to a well-known Michaelis-Menten elimination kinetics model and its variants. Results reported in this study show dependence of alcohol elimination rate (beta-slope) and BAC value. The analysis of beta60-slope versus BAC shows that a correlation between beta60 (y) and BAC (x) has a logarithmic trend line. The value of alcohol elimination rate shows a slight increment with increase of BAC alcohol, with the mean value of beta60 = 0.221 +/- 0.075 g/kg. Differences in values of beta60 among consecutive intervals of delta(BAC) = 0.1 g/kg are not significant (p>0.05). When obtained samples were grouped into ranges of 0.5 g/kg each in these intervals beta60 had the following values by range: 0.1-0.49 g/kg = 0.139 g/kg +/- 0.035; 0.5-0.99 g/kg = 0.184 g/kg +/- 0.043; 1-1.49 g/kg = 0.213 g/kg +/- 0.052; 1.5-1.99 g/kg = 0.239 g/kg +/- 0.058; 2-2.49 g/kg = 0.265 g/kg +/- 0.073; 2.5-2.99 g/kg = 0.306 g/kg +/- 0.096. Differences in values of beta slope among consecutive intervals of delta(BAC) = 0.5 g/kg are significant (p<0.01). The elimination curve in the BAC interval 0.5-2.5 g/kg has a linear trend, while beta-slope (y)/BAC (x) correlation is given as beta60 = 0.15 g/kg + (0.05 g/kg x BAC). Retrograde calculation of the blood alcohol concentration in tempore criminis (BAC(tc)) based on the determined alcohol concentration in the blood specimen (BAC(t)) shows a statistically significant difference between BAC(tc) calculated using a standard zero-order model versus corrected methodology. The higher the BAC(t) and the longer the calculation time, the greater and statistically more significant (p<0.01) is the difference between the calculated values of BAC(tc).
在1991年至2005年期间,诺维萨德法医学研究所采用顶空气相色谱法对2023例连续的血液样本进行了血液酒精浓度(BAC)分析。未考虑酒精浓度值为零的病例,以及犯罪行为发生后1小时内采集血液样本的病例。按照这一规则,本研究纳入了1198例病例,所有样本按照BAC1的29个范围进行分组,每组的δ(BAC)=0.1 g/kg,范围从0.1 - 0.19 g/kg到2.9 - 2.99 g/kg的纯酒精。收集的结果和消除曲线与维德马克提出的零级消除模型不同,表明消除过程类似于著名的米氏消除动力学模型及其变体。本研究报告的结果显示了酒精消除率(β斜率)与BAC值之间的相关性。β60斜率与BAC的分析表明,β60(y)与BAC(x)之间的相关性具有对数趋势线。酒精消除率的值随着BAC酒精含量的增加略有增加,β60的平均值为0.221±0.075 g/kg。在δ(BAC)=0.1 g/kg的连续区间内,β60值的差异不显著(p>0.05)。当在这些区间内将获得的样本按每个0.5 g/kg的范围进行分组时,β60按范围具有以下值:0.1 - 0.49 g/kg = 0.139 g/kg±0.035;0.5 - 0.99 g/kg = 0.184 g/kg±0.043;1 - 1.49 g/kg = 0.213 g/kg±0.052;1.5 - 1.99 g/kg = 0.239 g/kg±0.058;2 - 2.49 g/kg = 0.265 g/kg±0.073;2.5 - 2.99 g/kg = 0.306 g/kg±0.096。在δ(BAC)=0.5 g/kg的连续区间内,β斜率值的差异显著(p<0.01)。BAC区间0.5 - 2.5 g/kg内的消除曲线呈线性趋势,而β斜率(y)/BAC(x)的相关性表示为β60 = 0.15 g/kg +(0.05 g/kg×BAC)。根据血液样本中测定的酒精浓度(BAC(t))对犯罪时的血液酒精浓度(BAC(tc))进行逆向计算,结果显示使用标准零级模型计算的BAC(tc)与校正方法之间存在统计学显著差异。BAC(t)越高,计算时间越长,计算得到的BAC(tc)值之间的差异就越大且在统计学上越显著(p<0.01)。