Mills Peter R, Tomkins Susannah C, Schlangen Luc J M
Vielife Ltd, 68 Lombard Street, London EC3V 9LJ, UK.
J Circadian Rhythms. 2007 Jan 11;5:2. doi: 10.1186/1740-3391-5-2.
The effects of lighting on the human circadian system are well-established. The recent discovery of 'non-visual' retinal receptors has confirmed an anatomical basis for the non-image forming, biological effects of light and has stimulated interest in the use of light to enhance wellbeing in the corporate setting.
A prospective controlled intervention study was conducted within a shift-working call centre to investigate the effect of newly developed fluorescent light sources with a high correlated colour temperature (17000 K) upon the wellbeing, functioning and work performance of employees. Five items of the SF-36 questionnaire and a modification of the Columbia Jet Lag scale, were used to evaluate employees on two different floors of the call centre between February and May 2005. Questionnaire completion occurred at baseline and after a three month intervention period, during which time one floor was exposed to new high correlated colour temperature lighting and the other remained exposed to usual office lighting. Two sided t-tests with Bonferroni correction for type I errors were used to compare the characteristics of the two groups at baseline and to evaluate changes in the intervention and control groups over the period of the study.
Individuals in the intervention arm of the study showed a significant improvement in self-reported ability to concentrate at study end as compared to those within the control arm (p < 0.05). The mean individual score on a 5 point Likert scale improved by 36.8% in the intervention group, compared with only 1.7% in the control group. The majority of this improvement occurred within the first 7 weeks of the 14 week study. Substantial within group improvements were observed in the intervention group in the areas of fatigue (26.9%), alertness (28.2%), daytime sleepiness (31%) and work performance (19.4%), as assessed by the modified Columbia Scale, and in the areas of vitality (28.4%) and mental health (13.9%), as assessed by the SF-36 over the study period.
High correlated colour temperature fluorescent lights could provide a useful intervention to improve wellbeing and productivity in the corporate setting, although further work is necessary in quantifying the magnitude of likely benefits.
光照对人体昼夜节律系统的影响已得到充分证实。最近发现的“非视觉”视网膜受体证实了光的非成像生物效应的解剖学基础,并激发了人们对在企业环境中利用光来增进健康的兴趣。
在一个轮班制的呼叫中心进行了一项前瞻性对照干预研究,以调查新开发的具有高相关色温(17000K)的荧光光源对员工健康、功能和工作表现的影响。2005年2月至5月期间,使用SF-36问卷的五个项目和哥伦比亚时差量表的一个修改版本,对呼叫中心两层不同楼层的员工进行评估。问卷在基线时和三个月的干预期后完成,在此期间,一层暴露于新的高相关色温照明下,另一层仍暴露于普通办公室照明下。使用双侧t检验并采用Bonferroni校正法处理I型错误,以比较两组在基线时的特征,并评估研究期间干预组和对照组的变化。
与对照组相比,研究干预组的个体在研究结束时自我报告的注意力集中能力有显著改善(p<0.05)。干预组在5分量表上个体平均得分提高了36.8%,而对照组仅提高了1.7%。这种改善大部分发生在为期14周研究的前7周内。根据修改后的哥伦比亚量表评估,干预组在疲劳(26.9%)、警觉性(28.2%)、白天嗜睡(31%)和工作表现(19.4%)方面有显著的组内改善;根据SF-36评估,在活力(28.4%)和心理健康(13.9%)方面在研究期间也有显著改善。
高相关色温荧光灯可为改善企业环境中的健康和生产力提供有益的干预措施,不过在量化可能的益处程度方面还需要进一步研究。