Leys Didier, Ringelstein E Bernd, Kaste Markku, Hacke Werner
University of Lille, Lille, France.
Cerebrovasc Dis. 2007;23(5-6):344-52. doi: 10.1159/000099133. Epub 2007 Jan 30.
Stroke units decrease mortality, handicap and need for institutional care, but there are only sparse evidence-based data showing which components make the difference over general wards. The aim of this survey was to identify from expert opinions what should be the major components of stroke units.
A questionnaire was sent to 83 European stroke experts, to ask their opinion on what should be the components of comprehensive stroke centres (CSC), primary stroke centres (PSC) and any hospital ward (AHW) admitting acute stroke patients routinely. It consisted of a list of 107 components (personnel, diagnostic procedures, monitoring, invasive treatments provided, infrastructures, protocols and procedures and their availability for 24 h a day for 7 days a week, 24/7) to be classified as irrelevant, useful but not necessary, desirable, important but not absolutely necessary, or absolutely necessary.
42 questionnaires (50.6%) were returned. Four components were excluded because of a poor level of agreement between experts. Eight components were considered as absolutely necessary by more than 75% of the experts for both CSC and PSC: multidisciplinary team, stroke-trained nurses, brain CT scan 24/7, CT priority for stroke patients, extracranial Doppler sonography, automated electrocardiographic monitoring, intravenous rt-PA protocols 24/7 and in-house emergency department. Eleven other components (in the fields of vascular surgery, neurosurgery, interventional radiology and clinical research) were considered as necessary in CSC by more than 75% of the experts. Only 8 components were considered as important but not absolutely necessary by more than 50% of the experts for AHW.
The experts showed a high level of agreement about the essential components of organized acute stroke care, providing useful information to health authorities for the allocation of resources.
卒中单元可降低死亡率、残疾率并减少机构护理需求,但仅有少量基于证据的数据表明哪些组成部分能使其优于普通病房。本调查的目的是从专家意见中确定卒中单元的主要组成部分。
向83位欧洲卒中专家发放问卷,询问他们对于综合卒中中心(CSC)、初级卒中中心(PSC)以及任何常规收治急性卒中患者的医院病房(AHW)的组成部分的看法。问卷包含107个组成部分的列表(人员、诊断程序、监测、提供的侵入性治疗、基础设施、协议和程序以及它们每周7天、每天24小时的可用性,即全天候),这些组成部分被分类为不相关、有用但非必要、理想、重要但非绝对必要或绝对必要。
共收回42份问卷(50.6%)。由于专家之间的一致性水平较低,排除了4个组成部分。超过75%的专家认为CSC和PSC的8个组成部分是绝对必要的:多学科团队、接受过卒中培训的护士、全天候脑部CT扫描、卒中患者的CT优先、颅外多普勒超声检查、自动心电图监测、全天候静脉注射rt - PA协议以及医院内部急诊科。超过75%的专家认为CSC在血管外科、神经外科、介入放射学和临床研究领域的其他11个组成部分是必要的。对于AHW,只有8个组成部分被超过50%的专家认为是重要但非绝对必要的。
专家们对有组织的急性卒中护理的基本组成部分表现出高度一致性,为卫生当局分配资源提供了有用信息。