Papp Miklós, Csernátony Zoltán, Kazai Sándor, Károlyi Zoltán, Róde László
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Borsod County Hospital, 72-76 Szentpéteri kapu str., Miskolc 3501, Hungary.
Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2007 Jun;15(6):769-80. doi: 10.1007/s00167-006-0271-y. Epub 2007 Feb 6.
High tibial osteotomy changes the patella and tibial condyle position, which makes the subsequent total knee replacement technically demanding. From 1 January 1993 to 31 December 2000, combined osteotomy [After the first osteotomy made 2 cm distally to the joint line, a bone wedge is removed based laterally. Its tip ends at the center of the tibial condyle (half bone wedge). The distal part of the tibia is placed into the valgus position and the half bone wedge is placed into the gap opened medially.] was performed on 103 knees and closing wedge osteotomy was performed on 47 consecutive knees. Eighty combined (group A) and 41 closing wedge (group B) osteotomy were studied. All knees were assessed radiologically before surgery, in the 10th postoperative week, in the 12th postoperative month and at the time of the final follow-up (in group A-66.15 months, in group B-66.61 months). We examined the change of the femorotibial angle, of the patellar height according to the method of Insall and Salvati, of the tibial slope angle according to the method of Bonnin, of the tibial condylar offset according to the method of Yoshida and of the distance between the lateral tibial plateau and the top of the fibular head. In group A and B, the recurrence of the varus deformity was not noted and valgus alignment did not increase in any case. In group-A, the Insall-Salvati ratio remained unchanged in 65% of knees. The tibial slope angle decreased in both groups. There was correlation between the change of the tibial condylar offset and the angle of the correction in both groups. There was correlation between the change of the distance between the lateral tibial plateau and the top of the fibular head. After combined osteotomy, the transposition of the tibial condyle and the decrease of the distance between the lateral tibial plateau and the top of the fibular head was less than after closing wedge osteotomy, although the average angle of correction was more after combined osteotomy (11.835 degrees ), than after closing wedge osteotomy (9.465 degrees ). Theoretically, the recurrence of the varus deformity, the increase of the valgus alignment and (in majority of cases) the shortening of the patellar tendon do not compromise the likelihood of successful conversion to the subsequent total knee replacement, either after combined or after closing wedge osteotomy. The combined osteotomy does not lead to considerable transposition of the tibial condyle and to considerable lateral tibial bone loss; therefore, theoretically, the combined osteotomy does not impair the subsequent total knee replacement.
高位胫骨截骨术会改变髌骨和胫骨髁的位置,这使得随后的全膝关节置换术在技术上具有挑战性。从1993年1月1日至2000年12月31日,对103例膝关节实施了联合截骨术[在关节线远侧2 cm处进行首次截骨后,从外侧去除一个骨楔。其尖端止于胫骨髁中心(半骨楔)。将胫骨远端置于外翻位,将半骨楔置于内侧打开的间隙中。],并对连续47例膝关节实施了闭合楔形截骨术。研究了80例联合截骨术(A组)和41例闭合楔形截骨术(B组)。所有膝关节在术前、术后第10周、术后第12个月以及最终随访时(A组为66.15个月,B组为66.61个月)均进行了放射学评估。我们检查了股胫角、根据Insall和Salvati方法测量的髌骨高度、根据Bonnin方法测量的胫骨坡度角、根据Yoshida方法测量的胫骨髁偏移以及外侧胫骨平台与腓骨头顶部之间的距离的变化。在A组和B组中,均未发现内翻畸形复发,且在任何情况下外翻对线均未增加。在A组中,65%的膝关节Insall - Salvati比率保持不变。两组的胫骨坡度角均减小。两组中胫骨髁偏移的变化与矫正角度之间存在相关性。外侧胫骨平台与腓骨头顶部之间的距离变化也存在相关性。联合截骨术后,胫骨髁的移位以及外侧胫骨平台与腓骨头顶部之间距离的减小小于闭合楔形截骨术后,尽管联合截骨术后的平均矫正角度(11.835度)大于闭合楔形截骨术后(9.465度)。理论上,内翻畸形复发、外翻对线增加以及(在大多数情况下)髌腱缩短均不会影响随后成功转换为全膝关节置换术的可能性,无论是在联合截骨术还是闭合楔形截骨术后。联合截骨术不会导致胫骨髁的明显移位和外侧胫骨骨质的大量丢失;因此,理论上,联合截骨术不会损害随后的全膝关节置换术。