Tsibouris Panagiotis, Zintzaras Elias, Lappas Christos, Moussia Maria, Tsianos George, Galeas Theodoros, Potamianos Spyros
Department of Gastroenterology, Larissa University Hospital, Larissa, Greece.
Am J Gastroenterol. 2007 Jun;102(6):1192-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1572-0241.2007.01120.x. Epub 2007 Mar 22.
The best antisecretory treatment after endoscopic hemostasis in patients with ulcer bleeding is still in quest.
To compare pantoprazole and somatostatin continuous infusion after endoscopic hemostasis in patients with bleeding peptic ulcers.
A total of 164 consecutive patients with a bleeding peptic ulcer, after successful endoscopic hemostasis, were randomly assigned to receive, double blindly, continuous IV infusion of pantoprazole 8 mg/h for 48 h after a bolus of 40 mg (group P) or somatostatin 250 microg/h for 48 h after a bolus of 250 microg (group-S). Twenty-four-hour pH-metry was performed in the last 30 patients in each group. Endoscopy was performed, in case of bleeding nonrecurrence, every 48 h until disappearance of stigmata.
Bleeding recurrence: group S 14 patients (17%) versus group P 4 (5%) (P=0.046). In multivariate analysis, bleeding recurrence was 4.57 (CI 1.31-15.91) times more frequent in group S (P=0.02). There was no difference in the need for surgery and mortality. Acid suppression over pH 6: group S 82.9% of the time versus group P 81.5% (P=0.97). Acid suppression over pH 6 for >85% of the time: group S 14 (47%) patients versus group P 17 (57%) (P=0.44). Disappearance of endoscopic stigmata after 48 h: group S 25/68 patients (37%) versus group P 72/78 (92%) (P<0.0001). No major side effects identified in either study group.
In patients with a bleeding ulcer, after successful endoscopic hemostasis, despite equipotent acid suppression, pantoprazole continuous infusion was superior to somatostatin to prevent bleeding recurrence and quick disappearance of the endoscopic stigmata. Nevertheless, no differences were seen in the need for surgery and mortality.
溃疡出血患者内镜止血后的最佳抑酸治疗仍在探索中。
比较泮托拉唑和生长抑素持续输注用于消化性溃疡出血患者内镜止血后的效果。
164例连续性消化性溃疡出血患者在内镜止血成功后,被随机双盲分配,一组在静脉推注40mg后,以8mg/h的速度持续静脉输注泮托拉唑48小时(P组),另一组在静脉推注250μg后,以250μg/h的速度持续静脉输注生长抑素48小时(S组)。每组最后30例患者进行了24小时pH监测。若未再出血,则每48小时进行一次内镜检查,直至溃疡征象消失。
出血复发情况:S组14例(17%),P组4例(5%)(P = 0.046)。多因素分析显示,S组出血复发的频率是P组的4.57倍(95%置信区间1.31 - 15.91)(P = 0.02)。两组在手术需求和死亡率方面无差异。pH值>6时的抑酸情况:S组为82.9%的时间,P组为81.5%(P = 0.97)。pH值>6且时间>85%时的抑酸情况:S组14例(47%)患者,P组17例(57%)(P = 0.44)。48小时后内镜溃疡征象消失情况:S组25/68例患者(37%),P组72/78例(92%)(P<0.0001)。两个研究组均未发现严重副作用。
对于溃疡出血患者,在内镜止血成功后,尽管泮托拉唑和生长抑素的抑酸效果相当,但泮托拉唑持续输注在预防出血复发和促进内镜溃疡征象快速消失方面优于生长抑素。然而,两组在手术需求和死亡率方面无差异。