Baker Stephen R, Barry Maureen, Chaudhry Hamaira, Hubbi Basil
University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, Department of Radiology, Newark, NJ 07103-2496, USA.
J Am Coll Radiol. 2006 Feb;3(2):131-4. doi: 10.1016/j.jacr.2005.10.001.
In consideration of the fact that women constitute only 25% of radiology residents, even though they constitute 45% of medical students, this study was conducted to determine if the trend of women choosing radiology as a career differs from that for other medical specialties and if there are differences on the basis of the gender of program directors or geographic location. The authors also wished to determine if constraints exist that prevent women from advancing into positions of leadership in radiology.
The percentage of women in each of the 186 radiology residency programs was compiled to determine the mean and standard deviation of women represented and from those data to examine if there were patterns of exclusion related to program size, location, or the gender of program directors. The membership and committee lists of the ACR and the Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) were examined to gauge the participation of women as leaders in these 2 organizations, as were the mastheads of Radiology and the American Journal of Roentgenology. The number of female chairs of academic departments was also examined.
Over the past decade, the percentage of women in diagnostic radiology residencies has remained remarkably constant at or slightly above 25%. There was no discernable prejudice against women applicants by program size, location, or program director gender. In both the ACR and the RSNA, women are represented in positions of leadership approximately in proportion to their percentage in the general membership. Journal mastheads have fewer women than might be expected given the participation of women in academic radiology. There are a small but increasing number of women chairing academic radiology departments.
The relatively low percentage of women in diagnostic radiology residencies is not a reflection of the gender of program directors. Women are represented in positions of influence and authority in major organizations in American radiology in proportion to the overall number of women in the organization. However, women continue to be underrepresented in radiology chair positions. Explanations must be sought for the relative unattractiveness of radiology to prospective women residents and barriers to the advancement of women in academic radiology.
鉴于女性在放射科住院医师中仅占25%,尽管她们在医学生中占45%,本研究旨在确定女性选择放射科作为职业的趋势是否与其他医学专业不同,以及基于项目主任的性别或地理位置是否存在差异。作者还希望确定是否存在阻碍女性在放射科担任领导职位的限制因素。
汇总186个放射科住院医师培训项目中女性的百分比,以确定女性代表的均值和标准差,并根据这些数据检查是否存在与项目规模、地点或项目主任性别相关的排斥模式。审查了美国放射学会(ACR)和北美放射学会(RSNA)的会员和委员会名单,以衡量女性在这两个组织中担任领导的参与情况,放射学和《美国放射学杂志》的刊头也进行了审查。还审查了学术部门女性主席的数量。
在过去十年中,诊断放射科住院医师中女性的百分比一直保持在25%左右或略高于25%,相当稳定。在项目规模、地点或项目主任性别方面,对女性申请者没有明显的偏见。在ACR和RSNA中,女性担任领导职位的比例大致与其在普通会员中的百分比成正比。鉴于女性在学术放射学中的参与情况,期刊刊头中的女性人数比预期的要少。担任学术放射学部门主席的女性人数虽少,但在增加。
诊断放射科住院医师中女性比例相对较低并非项目主任性别的反映。在美国放射学主要组织中,女性在有影响力和权威的职位上的代表比例与该组织中女性的总数成正比。然而,女性在放射科主席职位上的代表性仍然不足。必须寻找放射学对未来女性住院医师缺乏吸引力的原因以及女性在学术放射学中晋升的障碍。