Hansen R, Seifeldin R, Noe L
Ovation Research Group, Health Economics, 188 Embarcadero, San Francisco, CA 94105, USA.
Transplant Proc. 2007 Jun;39(5):1287-300. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2007.02.074.
Poor medication adherence is a widespread problem that undermines the potential benefits of medical treatment. Typical adherence rates among chronic disease patients are approximately 50%, and these low adherence rates have a substantial economic impact, estimated at $100 to $300 billion annually. Nonadherence to immunosuppressants among transplant recipients is surprisingly frequent, and the consequences are serious. Among adult renal transplant patients, the median rate of nonadherence is approximately 22% and is associated with acute rejection episodes and approximately 36% of all graft losses. In the United States, nonadherence results in an estimated 903 episodes of acute rejection and 1319 renal transplants failures annually, costing approximately $15 million and $100 million, respectively. Drug regimen complexity is known to impact adherence. Research demonstrates an inverse relationship between dosing frequency and medication adherence in various chronic diseases, with once-daily dosing resulting in the highest adherence rates. Reducing the dosing frequency may positively impact both clinical and patient-reported outcomes, as well as health care costs. However, the increased costs of less frequently administered drugs must be outweighed by the net savings achieved through improved adherence rates and better health outcomes. If trends among patients with chronic diseases apply, once-daily dosing regimens may improve adherence rates by approximately 6% to 14% among renal transplant patients and could substantially reduce the number of acute rejection episodes and graft failures, although the exact economic impact is difficult to estimate. Further research into adherence issues in transplant patients and the potential clinical and economic benefits of once-daily dosing of immunosuppressants is warranted.
用药依从性差是一个普遍存在的问题,它会削弱医疗治疗的潜在益处。慢性病患者的典型依从率约为50%,而这些低依从率会产生重大的经济影响,估计每年为1000亿至3000亿美元。移植受者中不遵守免疫抑制剂治疗的情况出奇地频繁,后果严重。在成年肾移植患者中,不依从的中位数率约为22%,与急性排斥反应发作以及约36%的所有移植失败相关。在美国,不依从估计每年导致903次急性排斥反应发作和1319例肾移植失败,分别花费约1500万美元和1亿美元。已知药物治疗方案的复杂性会影响依从性。研究表明,在各种慢性病中,给药频率与用药依从性呈反比关系,每日一次给药的依从率最高。降低给药频率可能会对临床和患者报告的结果以及医疗保健成本产生积极影响。然而,较少给药频率的药物增加的成本必须被通过提高依从率和改善健康结果所实现的净节省所抵消。如果慢性病患者的趋势适用,每日一次给药方案可能会使肾移植患者的依从率提高约6%至14%,并可能大幅减少急性排斥反应发作和移植失败的数量,尽管确切的经济影响难以估计。有必要对移植患者的依从性问题以及免疫抑制剂每日一次给药的潜在临床和经济效益进行进一步研究。