Ide Kana, Mogami Hiroshi, Murakami Tadashi, Yasuhara Yoshifumi, Miyagawa Masao, Mochizuki Teruhito
Department of Radiology, Shikoku Cancer Center, Ehime University Postgraduate School of Medicine, 454 Shitsukawa, Toon, 791-0295, Japan.
Radiat Med. 2007 Jun;25(5):195-201. doi: 10.1007/s11604-007-0123-9. Epub 2007 Jun 27.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the detectability of lung cancer by chest radiography with a single-exposure dual-energy subtraction (ES) method.
Five radiologists read two sets of chest radiographs from 77 patients (66.5 +/- 9.6 years old) with histologically proven lung cancer measuring <or=3.0 cm and those from 77 normal subjects (65.7 +/- 9.0 years old). The observer tests were performed in two sessions: standard computed radiography (CR) images only and a combination of CR and ES images. Receiver-operating characteristic analysis was used for statistical analysis. All tumors were classified into three groups according to the appearance on thin-section CT: (1) nonsolid: tumor shadow disappearance rate (TDR) was 100%; (2) partly solid: TDR was >or=50 but <100%; (3) solid: TDR was <50%.
Overall, detectability with the ES method was significantly better than that without ES (mean Az value increased from 0.7673 to 0.8265, P < 0.05). In the subgroup analysis of the nonsolid group and the solid group detectability did not change using the ES method, whereas in the partly solid group detectability with the ES method was significantly better than that without ES (mean Az value increased from 0.7162 to 0.8209, P < 0.005).
The ES method improves the detectability of lung cancer by chest radiography, especially of the partly solid group.
本研究旨在评估采用单次曝光双能减影(ES)法的胸部X线摄影对肺癌的检测能力。
5名放射科医生阅读了两组胸部X线片,一组来自77例经组织学证实的肺癌患者(年龄66.5±9.6岁),肿瘤大小≤3.0 cm,另一组来自77名正常受试者(年龄65.7±9.0岁)。观察者测试分两个阶段进行:仅使用标准计算机X线摄影(CR)图像以及CR图像与ES图像相结合。采用受试者操作特征分析进行统计分析。所有肿瘤根据薄层CT表现分为三组:(1)非实性:肿瘤阴影消失率(TDR)为100%;(2)部分实性:TDR≥50%但<100%;(3)实性:TDR<50%。
总体而言,采用ES法的检测能力明显优于未采用ES法(平均Az值从0.7673增至0.8265,P<0.05)。在非实性组和实性组的亚组分析中,采用ES法时检测能力未发生变化,而在部分实性组中,采用ES法的检测能力明显优于未采用ES法(平均Az值从0.7162增至0.8209,P<0.005)。
ES法可提高胸部X线摄影对肺癌的检测能力,尤其是对部分实性组。