Mutlu Akmer, Livanelioglu Ayse, Gunel Mintaze Kerem
Cerebral Palsy Unit, School of Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation, Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey.
Med Sci Monit. 2007 Jul;13(7):CR323-9.
A prospective, cross-sectional, observational study was designed to determine the reliability of goniometric measurements in children with spastic diplegic cerebral palsy (CP).
MATERIAL/METHODS: The study included 38 children with spastic diplegic CP. Passive range of motion (PROM) of hip extension, abduction, and external rotation, hip flexion with knee extended, and ankle dorsi flexion was measured using universal goniometry. Each child was assessed by three physical therapists once in each session on two different sessions a week apart. Intra-test reliability was determined by paired comparison of measurements for each therapist across the two assessments. Inter-test reliability was determined by paired comparisons of the three therapists' measurements on the same session. The interclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was calculated for intra- and inter-test reliability.
The mean absolute differences for all measures between sessions ranged from 0.10-4.86 degrees for the three physical therapists. There was no statistical significance in the mean differences between the physical therapists in all measurements (p>0.05) except for hip flexion with the knee extended (p<0.05). Inter-test reliability was high (p<0.01). The highest ICC value was 0.95 for hip extension and the lowest was 0.61 for hip abduction. Although the intra-testing reliability scores were high for all the physiotherapists, the most experienced physiotherapists' results were higher compared with the others.
The results from this study encourage the use of goniometric measurements in assessing children with spastic diplegic CP.
一项前瞻性、横断面观察性研究旨在确定痉挛型双侧瘫脑瘫(CP)患儿角度测量的可靠性。
材料/方法:该研究纳入了38例痉挛型双侧瘫CP患儿。使用通用测角仪测量髋关节伸展、外展和外旋、膝关节伸展时的髋关节屈曲以及踝关节背屈的被动活动范围(PROM)。每周间隔两天,由三名物理治疗师对每个患儿进行两次评估。通过比较每位治疗师在两次评估中的测量结果来确定测试内可靠性。通过比较同一次评估中三名治疗师的测量结果来确定测试间可靠性。计算测试内和测试间可靠性的组内相关系数(ICC)。
三名物理治疗师在各次评估间所有测量的平均绝对差值范围为0.10 - 4.86度。除膝关节伸展时的髋关节屈曲外(p<0.05),所有测量中物理治疗师之间的平均差异无统计学意义(p>0.05)。测试间可靠性较高(p<0.01)。髋关节伸展的ICC最高值为0.95,髋关节外展的最低值为0.61。尽管所有物理治疗师的测试内可靠性得分都很高,但经验最丰富的物理治疗师的结果比其他治疗师更高。
本研究结果鼓励在评估痉挛型双侧瘫CP患儿时使用角度测量。