Kuo Chih-Hsi, Lin Shu-Min, Chen Ho-Chien, Chou Chu-Liang, Yu Chih-Ten, Kuo Han-Pin
Department of Thoracic Medicine, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Chang Gung School of Medicine, 199 Tun-Hwa N Rd, Taipei, Taiwan.
Chest. 2007 Sep;132(3):922-9. doi: 10.1378/chest.06-3106. Epub 2007 Jul 23.
Endobronchial ultrasonography (EBUS) is useful in localizing peripheral lung lesions. Previous reports have revealed that several characteristic echoic patterns correlate well with the histopathologic findings of benign and malignant lesions. Therefore, EBUS may be also useful in the differential diagnosis of malignant lesions of the lung.
To assess the feasibility of EBUS in the differential diagnosis between malignant and benign lesions by the following three characteristic echoic features indicating malignancy: continuous margin; absence of a linear-discrete air bronchogram; and heterogeneous echogenicity.
EBUS images from 224 patients who undergone bronchoscopy for a peripheral lung lesion were analyzed. The sensitivity and specificity for each echoic feature or in combination in diagnosing malignancy or benignity were determined.
Continuous margin, absence of linear-discrete air bronchogram, and heterogeneous echogenicity are three echoic features indicating malignancy. The absence of linear-discrete air bronchogram has the highest sensitivity in the diagnosis of malignancy (91.9%), but the lowest specificity (62.4%). By contrast, a well-defined margin has the highest specificity (93.1%), but the lowest sensitivity (27.6%). The sensitivity and specificity for heterogeneous echogenicity are intermediate (65.0% and 90.1%, respectively). The negative predictive value for the malignancy of a lesion with none of these three echoic features is 93.7%. The positive predictive value for malignancy of a lesion with any two of the three echoic features is 89.2%.
These results indicate that EBUS is useful as an adjunct in lung cancer diagnosis, especially when peripheral lung lesions are not visible in traditional bronchoscopy.
支气管内超声检查(EBUS)有助于定位外周肺病变。既往报告显示,几种特征性回声模式与良性和恶性病变的组织病理学结果密切相关。因此,EBUS在肺恶性病变的鉴别诊断中可能也有帮助。
通过以下三种提示恶性病变的特征性回声特征评估EBUS在恶性与良性病变鉴别诊断中的可行性:边界连续;无线性离散空气支气管造影;回声不均匀。
分析了224例因外周肺病变接受支气管镜检查患者的EBUS图像。确定了每种回声特征或其组合在诊断恶性或良性病变中的敏感性和特异性。
边界连续、无线性离散空气支气管造影和回声不均匀是提示恶性病变的三种回声特征。无线性离散空气支气管造影在诊断恶性病变中敏感性最高(91.9%),但特异性最低(62.4%)。相比之下,边界清晰特异性最高(93.1%),但敏感性最低(27.6%)。回声不均匀的敏感性和特异性居中(分别为65.0%和90.1%)。无这三种回声特征中任何一种的病变对恶性病变的阴性预测值为93.7%。具有三种回声特征中任意两种的病变对恶性病变的阳性预测值为89.2%。
这些结果表明,EBUS作为肺癌诊断的辅助手段是有用的,尤其是在外周肺病变在传统支气管镜检查中不可见时。