Conry C M, Pace W D, Main D S
Department of Family Medicine, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Denver.
J Am Board Fam Pract. 1991 Nov-Dec;4(6):399-406.
Because an estimated 70 percent of all medical care expenditures are generated by physicians, evaluation of specialty practice styles is essential to learn what changes in policies governing physician training, service delivery, and patterns of medical practice would promote cost containment.
We examined the 1981 and 1985 National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey for seven primary care diagnoses to compare practice style differences between family physicians and internists and to look for changes in family physicians' practice styles between 1981 and 1985.
Family physicians referred fewer patients in 1985 and spent 3 to 10.5 minutes less per patient encounter than internists. Clinical laboratory testing, electrocardiogram (ECG) ordering, and radiographic examinations differed significantly between the two groups in 1981 and 1985 for some diagnoses. In 1981, family physicians did Papanicolaou smears 2.2 times more often than internists during general medical examinations; however, in 1985, there was no difference. Between 1981 and 1985, family physicians ordered significantly more laboratory tests and ECGs for some diagnoses but had no change in the number of radiographs ordered or referrals. For six diagnoses, they spent more time with a patient encounter in 1985 than in 1981.
Family physicians and internists appear to be more alike in practice style, but significant differences remain. These differences, as well as changing practice styles of family physicians, have implications for training and health care resource distribution.
由于估计所有医疗保健支出的70%是由医生产生的,因此评估专科医生的执业方式对于了解在医生培训、服务提供和医疗执业模式方面的政策变化如何促进成本控制至关重要。
我们研究了1981年和1985年的全国门诊医疗调查中七种初级保健诊断情况,以比较家庭医生和内科医生之间的执业方式差异,并寻找1981年至1985年间家庭医生执业方式的变化。
1985年家庭医生转诊的患者较少,每次患者诊疗花费的时间比内科医生少3至10.5分钟。在1981年和1985年,对于某些诊断,两组之间的临床实验室检查、心电图(ECG)开具和影像学检查存在显著差异。1981年,在普通体检期间,家庭医生进行巴氏涂片检查的频率是内科医生的2.2倍;然而,1985年,两者没有差异。在1981年至1985年间,对于某些诊断,家庭医生开具的实验室检查和心电图显著增多,但影像学检查开具数量或转诊数量没有变化。对于六种诊断,他们在1985年每次患者诊疗花费的时间比1981年更多。
家庭医生和内科医生在执业方式上似乎更为相似,但仍存在显著差异。这些差异以及家庭医生不断变化的执业方式对培训和医疗保健资源分配具有影响。