Prasad Prabhudev, Sen Ramesh K, Gill Shivender S, Wardak Emal, Saini Raghav
Department of Orthopaedics, PGIMER, O- Block, # 296, MDH, PGIMER, Sector-12, Chandigarh, 160012, India.
Int Orthop. 2009 Feb;33(1):225-9. doi: 10.1007/s00264-007-0448-0. Epub 2007 Sep 4.
The controversy regarding the radiographic parameter which best represents the various deformities of clubfoot continues. The aim of our study was to clear up this controversy. Fifty surgically treated (soft-tissue release) congenital clubfeet were studied clinically using Laaveg and Ponseti score and radiologically using twelve different radiographic parameters in weight-bearing AP and lateral views. The talo-calcaneal angle (TCA) in AP and lateral view showed statistically significant correlation with the functional rating, but significant variation in the dimension of the angles among the different functional groups was found with AP angle only. The talo-first metatarsal angle in AP and lateral view averaged 10 degrees and 19 degrees respectively, and showed significant correlation with the functional rating. The talo-navicular subluxation in AP, the calcaneo-fifth metatarsal angle and the first-fifth metatarsal angle in lateral view did not show any significant correlation with function. Talo-calcaneal index averaged 44 degrees in the clubfeet and showed significant correlation. The wide range of parameters representing each of the deformities gives a better radiological assessment of the clubfoot than any single parameter.
关于最能代表马蹄内翻足各种畸形的影像学参数的争议仍在继续。我们研究的目的是澄清这一争议。对50例接受手术治疗(软组织松解)的先天性马蹄内翻足进行了临床研究,采用Laaveg和Ponseti评分,以及在负重前后位和侧位片上使用12种不同的影像学参数进行放射学研究。前后位和侧位片上的距跟角(TCA)与功能评分具有统计学意义的相关性,但仅在前后位角中发现不同功能组之间角度大小存在显著差异。前后位和侧位片上的距第一跖骨角平均分别为10度和19度,且与功能评分具有显著相关性。前后位片上的距舟半脱位、侧位片上的跟骨-第五跖骨角和第一-第五跖骨角与功能均无显著相关性。马蹄内翻足的距跟指数平均为44度,且具有显著相关性。与任何单一参数相比,代表每种畸形的广泛参数能对马蹄内翻足进行更好的放射学评估。