Harris-Haywood Sonja, Sylvia-Bobiak Sarah N, Stange Kurt C, Flocke Susan A
Department of Family Medicine--Research Division, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH 44106, USA.
J Natl Med Assoc. 2007 Sep;99(9):1061-5.
Both satisfaction with the physician and how time is spent in the patient-physician outpatient visit have been shown to differ between African-American and Caucasian patients. This study uses structural equation modeling to examine racial differences in the association between time use during the outpatient visit and patient satisfaction. This cross-sectional study employed direct observation of outpatient visits and surveys of 2,502 adult African-American and Caucasian outpatients visiting 138 primary care physicians in 84 family practices in Northeast Ohio. Patient satisfaction was measured using the Medical Outcome Study (MOS) nine-item Visit Rating Scale. Time use was assessed with the Davis Observation Code, which was used to classify every 20 seconds of a visit into 20 behavioral categories. No difference was found between African-American and Caucasian patients in the association between patient satisfaction with a physician and the time the physician spent chatting, planning treatment, providing health education, structuring the interaction, assessing health knowledge or answering patient questions. Patients were generally satisfied with their physicians, and no racial differences between Caucasians and African Americans were observed. Despite racial differences in how physicians spend time in the outpatient visit encounter, these differences are not associated with racial differences in patient satisfaction. Efforts to understand disparities in satisfaction should address areas other than how physicians allocate time in the physician-patient encounter.
研究表明,非裔美国患者和白人患者对医生的满意度以及在医患门诊就诊过程中时间的利用方式存在差异。本研究使用结构方程模型来检验门诊就诊期间时间利用与患者满意度之间关联的种族差异。这项横断面研究对俄亥俄州东北部84个家庭医疗诊所中138名初级保健医生接待的2502名成年非裔美国患者和白人门诊患者的就诊情况进行了直接观察并开展了调查。患者满意度采用医疗结果研究(MOS)的九项就诊评分量表进行测量。时间利用情况通过戴维斯观察代码进行评估,该代码用于将每次就诊的每20秒划分为20种行为类别。在患者对医生的满意度与医生用于聊天、制定治疗计划、提供健康教育、组织互动、评估健康知识或回答患者问题的时间之间的关联方面,未发现非裔美国患者和白人患者存在差异。患者总体上对他们的医生感到满意,未观察到白人和非裔美国人之间存在种族差异。尽管医生在门诊就诊过程中时间利用方式存在种族差异,但这些差异与患者满意度的种族差异无关。理解满意度差异的努力应着眼于医患互动中医生分配时间以外的其他领域。