van Houwelingen Cornelis A J, Kerkhof Ad J F M
GGz Eindhoven, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.
J Affect Disord. 2008 Apr;107(1-3):281-4. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2007.08.024. Epub 2007 Oct 25.
The objective of this study is to investigate mental healthcare status and psychiatric disorders in train suicides.
Data of 4 published train suicide studies were combined with a study of 57 train suicides in The Netherlands.
53% of all train suicides received psychiatric care at the time of suicide, with 49% of them being inpatients. These values are higher than those found in general suicides. When compared to general suicides, functional non-affective psychoses are overrepresented by 25% vs 14%. The percentage of affective disorders approximates that of general suicides namely: 39% vs 42%. "Other diagnoses" are underrepresented by 23% vs 40%.
All psychiatric diagnoses were based on clinical data, which may not accurately reflect the patient's psychiatric condition at the time of suicide.
Train suicides receive mental healthcare more often than general suicides and are more often characterized by severe psychopathology. The study indicates that patients with affective and psychotic disorders in particular should be targeted in order to prevent train suicide.
本研究的目的是调查列车自杀事件中的精神卫生保健状况和精神障碍。
将4项已发表的列车自杀研究数据与荷兰一项针对57例列车自杀事件的研究相结合。
所有列车自杀者中有53%在自杀时接受过精神科护理,其中49%为住院患者。这些数值高于一般自杀情况中的数值。与一般自杀相比,功能性非情感性精神病在列车自杀中所占比例比一般自杀高25%(一般自杀中为14%)。情感障碍的比例与一般自杀相近,分别为39%和42%。“其他诊断”在列车自杀中所占比例比一般自杀低23%(一般自杀中为40%)。
所有精神科诊断均基于临床数据,可能无法准确反映患者自杀时的精神状况。
列车自杀者比一般自杀者更常接受精神卫生保健,且更常具有严重精神病理学特征。该研究表明,为预防列车自杀,应特别关注情感障碍和精神障碍患者。