Atkins Clarke E, Keene Bruce W, Brown William A, Coats Julie R, Crawford Mary Ann, DeFrancesco Teresa C, Edwards N Joel, Fox Phillip R, Lehmkuhl Linda B, Luethy Michael W, Meurs Kathryn M, Petrie Jean-Paul, Pipers Frank S, Rosenthal Steven L, Sidley Jennifer A, Straus Justin H
Department of Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC 27606, USA.
J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2007 Oct 1;231(7):1061-9. doi: 10.2460/javma.231.7.1061.
To determine the efficacy of long-term enalapril administration in delaying the onset of congestive heart failure (CHF).
Placebo-controlled, double-blind, multicenter, randomized trial.
124 dogs with compensated mitral valve regurgitation (MR).
Dogs randomly assigned to receive enalapril or placebo were monitored for the primary endpoint of onset of CHF for < or = 58 months. Secondary endpoints included time from study entry to the combined endpoint of CHF-all-cause death; number of dogs free of CHF at 500, 1,000, and 1,500 days; and mean number of CHF-free days.
Kaplan-Meier estimates of the effect of enalapril on the primary endpoint did not reveal a significant treatment benefit. Chronic enalapril administration did have a significant benefit on the combined endpoint of CHF-all-cause death (benefit was 317 days [10.6 months]). Dogs receiving enalapril remained free of CHF for a significantly longer time than those receiving placebo and were significantly more likely to be free of CHF at day 500 and at study end.
Chronic enalapril treatment of dogs with naturally occurring, moderate to severe MR significantly delayed onset of CHF, compared with placebo, on the basis of number of CHF-free days, number of dogs free of CHF at days 500 and study end, and increased time to a combined secondary endpoint of CHF-all-cause death. Improvement in the primary endpoint, CHF-free survival, was not significant. Results suggest that enalapril modestly delays the onset of CHF in dogs with moderate to severe MR.
确定长期服用依那普利在延缓充血性心力衰竭(CHF)发作方面的疗效。
安慰剂对照、双盲、多中心随机试验。
124只患有代偿性二尖瓣反流(MR)的犬。
将犬随机分为接受依那普利或安慰剂组,监测CHF发作这一主要终点长达≤58个月。次要终点包括从研究开始至CHF-全因死亡这一联合终点的时间;在500天、1000天和1500天时无CHF的犬的数量;以及无CHF天数的均值。
依那普利对主要终点影响的Kaplan-Meier估计未显示出显著的治疗益处。长期服用依那普利对CHF-全因死亡这一联合终点确实有显著益处(益处为317天[10.6个月])。接受依那普利的犬无CHF的时间明显长于接受安慰剂的犬,并且在500天时和研究结束时无CHF的可能性显著更高。
基于无CHF天数、在500天时和研究结束时无CHF的犬的数量以及至CHF-全因死亡这一联合次要终点的时间增加,与安慰剂相比,对自然发生中度至重度MR的犬长期使用依那普利可显著延迟CHF的发作。主要终点无CHF生存期的改善不显著。结果表明依那普利可适度延迟中度至重度MR犬CHF的发作。