Schneider R, Kluge R, Willmes K
Department of Neurology, Rheinisch-Westfällische Technische Hochschule, Aachen, Germany.
Acta Neurol Scand. 1991 Dec;84(6):527-30. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0404.1991.tb05007.x.
A total of 74 CT scans from patients with lacunar syndromes were presented to 10 raters, most of them experienced in neuroradiology. The attributes to be judged were: lacunar infarcts (yes/no), leuko-araiosis (decreased density of the cerebral white matter) (yes/no), cortical atrophy (yes/no), and normal (yes/no). The chance corrected kappa coefficients were 0.641 for decreased density, 0.445 for lacunar infarcts and 0.206 for cortical atrophy. Taking into consideration the attribute cortical atrophy, the kappa coefficient for the attribute normal was 0.330, and without taking cortical atrophy into consideration, it was 0.523. Studies of lacunar infarcts and of leuko-araiosis should be based on clear definitions in order to guarantee a minimum level of interrater agreement.
总共向10位评分者展示了74例腔隙综合征患者的CT扫描图像,其中大多数评分者在神经放射学方面经验丰富。需要判断的特征包括:腔隙性梗死(是/否)、脑白质疏松(脑白质密度降低)(是/否)、皮质萎缩(是/否)以及正常(是/否)。密度降低的机会校正kappa系数为0.641,腔隙性梗死为0.445,皮质萎缩为0.206。考虑到皮质萎缩这一特征,正常这一特征的kappa系数为0.330,不考虑皮质萎缩时为0.523。对腔隙性梗死和脑白质疏松的研究应基于明确的定义,以确保评分者间的一致性达到最低水平。