Thomas Katharine, Yaphe John, Matalon Andre
Department of Family Medicine, Rabin Medical Center (Beilinson Campus), Petah Tikva, Israel.
Isr Med Assoc J. 2007 Sep;9(9):645-8.
Smoking continues to be the most significant preventable cause of morbidity and early mortality in the developed world. Primary care physicians are not fufilling their potentially vital and effective role with regard to tobacco use and dependence.
To evaluate current primary care physician practise in promoting smoking cessation.
This observational study evaluated physician recording of smoking status by analysis of patients' electronic medical records. The 126 primary care physicians were based in 23 Tel Aviv clinics treating 144,811 patients. We also assessed additional physician anti-smoking activities by a telephone questionnaire of 178 randomly selected patients.
Analysis of the EMRs revealed that an average of 4.4% of patients per physician were recorded as smokers (as compared to a known smoking rate in this patient population of 24%). Male physicians recorded a significantly higher proportion of their patients as smokers in the EMR compared to female physicians (P < 0.05). A non-significantly higher rate of recording smokers was found in doctors who had completed postgraduate specialization in family medicine as compared to non-specialists. The questionnaire results show that 41% of patients interviewed recalled being asked if they smoked and 31% of smoking patients had been advised to quit. A non-significantly higher proportion of male as compared to female patients reported being questioned if they smoked, and if they were smokers, being advised to quit.
This study shows low rates of physician intervention to promote smoking cessation. It appears that a large proportion of the primary care physicians surveyed do not follow recommendations to promote smoking cessation among their patients. Intervention among adolesent smokers was particularly inadequate. Further action is needed to improve the performance of physicians in aiding smoking cessation.
在发达国家,吸烟仍是可预防的发病和过早死亡的最主要原因。初级保健医生在烟草使用和依赖问题上未发挥其潜在的关键且有效的作用。
评估当前初级保健医生在促进戒烟方面的实践情况。
这项观察性研究通过分析患者的电子病历评估医生对吸烟状况的记录。126名初级保健医生来自特拉维夫的23家诊所,共治疗144,811名患者。我们还通过对178名随机选择的患者进行电话问卷调查,评估医生的其他戒烟活动。
对电子病历的分析显示,每位医生记录为吸烟者的患者平均占4.4%(而该患者群体已知的吸烟率为24%)。在电子病历中,男医生记录为吸烟者的患者比例显著高于女医生(P < 0.05)。与非专科医生相比,完成家庭医学研究生专业培训的医生记录吸烟者的比例略高,但无显著差异。问卷调查结果显示,41%的受访患者回忆被问及是否吸烟,31%的吸烟患者被建议戒烟。报告被问及是否吸烟以及若吸烟是否被建议戒烟的男性患者比例略高于女性患者,但无显著差异。
本研究表明医生促进戒烟的干预率较低。看来,接受调查的大部分初级保健医生未遵循在患者中促进戒烟的建议。对青少年吸烟者的干预尤其不足。需要采取进一步行动来提高医生在协助戒烟方面的表现。