Kiecolt-Glaser Janice K, Graham Jennifer E, Malarkey William B, Porter Kyle, Lemeshow Stanley, Glaser Ronald
Department of Psychiatry, The Ohio State University, 1670 Upham Drive, Columbus, OH 43210, USA.
Psychoneuroendocrinology. 2008 Apr;33(3):328-39. doi: 10.1016/j.psyneuen.2007.11.015.
Despite aromatherapy's popularity, efficacy data are scant, and potential mechanisms are controversial. This randomized controlled trial examined the psychological, autonomic, endocrine, and immune consequences of one purported relaxant odor (lavender), one stimulant odor (lemon), and a no-odor control (water), before and after a stressor (cold pressor); 56 healthy men and women were exposed to each of the odors during three separate visits. To assess the effects of expectancies, participants randomized to the "blind" condition were given no information about the odors they would smell; "primed" individuals were told what odors they would smell during the session, and what changes to expect. Experimenters were blind. Self-report and unobtrusive mood measures provided robust evidence that lemon oil reliably enhances positive mood compared to water and lavender regardless of expectancies or previous use of aromatherapy. Moreover, norepinephrine levels following the cold pressor remained elevated when subjects smelled lemon, compared to water or lavender. DTH responses to Candida were larger following inhalation of water than lemon or lavender. Odors did not reliably alter IL-6 and IL-10 production, salivary cortisol, heart rate or blood pressure, skin barrier repair following tape stripping, or pain ratings following the cold pressor.
尽管芳香疗法很受欢迎,但疗效数据匮乏,其潜在机制也存在争议。这项随机对照试验研究了在施加应激源(冷加压试验)前后,一种据称具有放松作用的气味(薰衣草)、一种具有刺激作用的气味(柠檬)以及无气味对照(水)对心理、自主神经、内分泌和免疫方面的影响;56名健康男性和女性在三次单独的访视中分别接触每种气味。为了评估预期的影响,被随机分配到“盲法”组的参与者未被告知他们将闻到的气味信息;“预先告知”组的个体被告知他们在试验过程中将闻到的气味以及预期会发生的变化。实验人员是盲法操作。自我报告和客观的情绪测量提供了有力证据,表明与水和薰衣草相比,无论预期如何或之前是否使用过芳香疗法,柠檬油都能可靠地增强积极情绪。此外,与闻水或薰衣草相比,当受试者闻柠檬时,冷加压试验后的去甲肾上腺素水平仍保持升高。吸入水后对白色念珠菌的迟发型超敏反应比吸入柠檬或薰衣草后更大。气味并未可靠地改变白细胞介素-6和白细胞介素-10的产生、唾液皮质醇、心率或血压、胶带剥离后的皮肤屏障修复,或冷加压试验后的疼痛评分。