Childress Anna Rose, Ehrman Ronald N, Wang Ze, Li Yin, Sciortino Nathan, Hakun Jonathan, Jens William, Suh Jesse, Listerud John, Marquez Kathleen, Franklin Teresa, Langleben Daniel, Detre John, O'Brien Charles P
Department of Psychiatry, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
PLoS One. 2008 Jan 30;3(1):e1506. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0001506.
The human brain responds to recognizable signals for sex and for rewarding drugs of abuse by activation of limbic reward circuitry. Does the brain respond in similar way to such reward signals even when they are "unseen", i.e., presented in a way that prevents their conscious recognition? Can the brain response to "unseen" reward cues predict the future affective response to recognizable versions of such cues, revealing a link between affective/motivational processes inside and outside awareness?
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: We exploited the fast temporal resolution of event-related functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to test the brain response to "unseen" (backward-masked) cocaine, sexual, aversive and neutral cues of 33 milliseconds duration in male cocaine patients (n = 22). Two days after scanning, the affective valence for visible versions of each cue type was determined using an affective bias (priming) task. We demonstrate, for the first time, limbic brain activation by "unseen" drug and sexual cues of only 33 msec duration. Importantly, increased activity in an large interconnected ventral pallidum/amygdala cluster to the "unseen" cocaine cues strongly predicted future positive affect to visible versions of the same cues in subsequent off-magnet testing, pointing both to the functional significance of the rapid brain response, and to shared brain substrates for appetitive motivation within and outside awareness.
CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE: These findings represent the first evidence that brain reward circuitry responds to drug and sexual cues presented outside awareness. The results underscore the sensitivity of the brain to "unseen" reward signals and may represent the brain's primordial signature for desire. The limbic brain response to reward cues outside awareness may represent a potential vulnerability in disorders (e.g., the addictions) for whom poorly-controlled appetitive motivation is a central feature.
人类大脑通过激活边缘奖赏回路对可识别的性信号及滥用的成瘾性药物信号作出反应。即使这些奖赏信号是“不可见的”,即以一种防止其被有意识识别的方式呈现时,大脑是否也会以类似方式作出反应?大脑对“不可见”奖赏线索的反应能否预测其对这些线索可识别版本的未来情感反应,从而揭示意识内外情感/动机过程之间的联系?
方法/主要发现:我们利用事件相关功能磁共振成像(fMRI)的快速时间分辨率,测试了男性可卡因成瘾患者(n = 22)对持续33毫秒的“不可见”(逆向掩蔽)可卡因、性、厌恶及中性线索的大脑反应。扫描两天后,使用情感偏差(启动)任务确定每种线索类型可见版本的情感效价。我们首次证明,持续仅33毫秒的“不可见”药物和性线索可激活边缘脑区。重要的是,一个大的相互连接的腹侧苍白球/杏仁核簇对“不可见”可卡因线索的活动增加,有力地预测了在随后的非磁共振测试中对相同线索可见版本的未来积极情感,这既表明了快速大脑反应的功能意义,也表明了意识内外食欲动机的共享脑底物。
结论/意义:这些发现首次证明大脑奖赏回路对意识之外呈现的药物和性线索作出反应。结果强调了大脑对“不可见”奖赏信号的敏感性,可能代表了大脑对欲望的原始特征。边缘脑区对意识之外奖赏线索的反应可能代表了某些疾病(如成瘾)中的潜在脆弱性,在这些疾病中,食欲动机控制不佳是一个核心特征。