Maniwa Kazumi, Jongman Allard, Wade Travis
Department of Linguistics, The University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas 66044, USA.
J Acoust Soc Am. 2008 Feb;123(2):1114-25. doi: 10.1121/1.2821966.
Speakers may adapt the phonetic details of their productions when they anticipate perceptual difficulty or comprehension failure on the part of a listener. Previous research suggests that a speaking style known as clear speech is more intelligible overall than casual, conversational speech for a variety of listener populations. However, it is unknown whether clear speech improves the intelligibility of fricative consonants specifically, or how its effects on fricative perception might differ depending on listener population. The primary goal of this study was to determine whether clear speech enhances fricative intelligibility for normal-hearing listeners and listeners with simulated impairment. Two experiments measured babble signal-to-noise ratio thresholds for fricative minimal pair distinctions for 14 normal-hearing listeners and 14 listeners with simulated sloping, recruiting impairment. Results indicated that clear speech helped both groups overall. However, for impaired listeners, reliable clear speech intelligibility advantages were not found for non-sibilant pairs. Correlation analyses comparing acoustic and perceptual data indicated that a shift of energy concentration toward higher frequency regions and greater source strength contributed to the clear speech effect for normal-hearing listeners. Correlations between acoustic and perceptual data were less consistent for listeners with simulated impairment, and suggested that lower-frequency information may play a role.
当说话者预料到听众可能会在感知上遇到困难或理解失败时,他们可能会调整自己发音的语音细节。先前的研究表明,对于各类听众群体而言,一种被称为清晰言语的说话风格总体上比随意的会话言语更易懂。然而,尚不清楚清晰言语是否能特别提高擦音的可懂度,也不清楚其对擦音感知的影响会因听众群体的不同而有何差异。本研究的主要目的是确定清晰言语是否能提高听力正常的听众以及有模拟听力损伤的听众对擦音的可懂度。两项实验测量了14名听力正常的听众和14名有模拟斜坡型、重振型听力损伤的听众对擦音最小对立体区别的噪声干扰下的言语信号比阈值。结果表明,清晰言语总体上对两组听众都有帮助。然而,对于有听力损伤的听众,在非咝音对立体方面未发现可靠的清晰言语可懂度优势。比较声学数据和感知数据的相关分析表明,能量集中向高频区域的转移以及更大的声源强度促成了听力正常的听众的清晰言语效应。对于有模拟听力损伤的听众,声学数据和感知数据之间的相关性不太一致,这表明低频信息可能起了作用。