Armstrong D, Barkun A Ng, Chen Y, Daniels S, Hollingworth R, Hunt R H, Leddin D
McMaster Health Sciences Centre, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Can J Gastroenterol. 2008 Feb;22(2):155-60. doi: 10.1155/2008/292948.
Canadian wait time data are available for the treatment of cancer and heart disease, as well as for joint replacement, cataract surgery and diagnostic imaging procedures. Wait times for gastroenterology consultation and procedures have not been studied, although digestive diseases pose a greater economic burden in Canada than cancer or heart disease.
Specialist physicians completed the practice audit if they provided digestive health care, accepted new patients and recorded referral dates. For patients seen for consultation or investigation over a one-week period, preprogrammed personal digital assistants were used to collect data including the main reason for referral, initial referral and consultation dates, procedure dates (if performed), personal and family history, and patient symptoms, signs and test results. Patient triaging, appropriateness of the referral and timeliness of care were noted.
Over 10 months, 199 physicians recorded details of 5559 referrals, including 1903 visits for procedures. The distribution of total wait times (from referral to procedure) nationally was highly skewed at 91/203 days (median/75th percentile), with substantial interprovincial variation: British Columbia, 66/185 days; Alberta, 134/284 days; Ontario, 110/208 days; Quebec, 71/149 days; New Brunswick, 104/234 days; and Nova Scotia, 42/84 days. The percentage of physicians by province offering average-risk screening colonoscopy varied from 29% to 100%.
Access to specialist gastroenterology care in Canada is limited by long wait times, which exceed clinically reasonable waits for specialist treatment. Although exhibiting some methodological limitations, this large practice audit sampling offers broadly generalized results, as well as a means to identify barriers to health care delivery and evaluate strategies to address these barriers, with the goals of expediting appropriate care for patients with digestive health disorders and ameliorating the personal and societal burdens imposed by digestive diseases.
加拿大有癌症、心脏病治疗以及关节置换、白内障手术和诊断成像程序的等待时间数据。尽管消化系统疾病在加拿大造成的经济负担比癌症或心脏病更大,但胃肠病学咨询和程序的等待时间尚未得到研究。
如果专科医生提供消化健康护理、接收新患者并记录转诊日期,则完成实践审计。对于在一周内接受咨询或检查的患者,使用预编程的个人数字助理收集数据,包括转诊的主要原因、初始转诊和咨询日期、程序日期(如果进行了程序)、个人和家族病史以及患者症状、体征和检查结果。记录患者分诊、转诊的适当性和护理的及时性。
在10个多月的时间里,199名医生记录了5559次转诊的详细信息,包括1903次程序就诊。全国总等待时间(从转诊到程序)的分布严重偏斜,为91/203天(中位数/第75百分位数),省际差异很大:不列颠哥伦比亚省,66/185天;艾伯塔省,134/284天;安大略省,110/208天;魁北克省,71/149天;新不伦瑞克省,104/234天;新斯科舍省,42/84天。各省提供平均风险筛查结肠镜检查的医生比例从29%到100%不等。
加拿大专科胃肠病护理的可及性受到长时间等待的限制,这超过了专科治疗临床上合理的等待时间。尽管存在一些方法上的局限性,但这种大型实践审计抽样提供了广泛的一般性结果,以及一种识别医疗服务提供障碍并评估解决这些障碍策略的方法,目标是加快对消化健康疾病患者的适当护理,并减轻消化系统疾病造成的个人和社会负担。