Bartsch Georg, Horninger Wolfgang, Klocker Helmut, Pelzer Alexandre, Bektic Jasmin, Oberaigner Wilhelm, Schennach Harald, Schäfer Georg, Frauscher Ferdinand, Boniol Mathieu, Severi Gianluca, Robertson Chris, Boyle Peter
Department of Urology, University of Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Austria.
BJU Int. 2008 Apr;101(7):809-16. doi: 10.1111/j.1464-410X.2008.07502.x.
To evaluate the effectiveness of a well-controlled programme of early detection and treatment of prostate cancer in the population of Tyrol, Austria, where such a programme of early detection and treatment was initiated in 1988 and where prostate-specific antigen (PSA) testing was offered for free to all men aged 45-75 years from 1993.
Comparison of prostate cancer mortality rates in Tyrol and the rest of Austria was accomplished through a generalized additive model. A piecewise linear change-point Poisson regression model was used to compare mortality rates in Tyrol and the rest of Austria. Standardized mortality ratios were calculated with reference to the mortality rates in 1986-1990.
In all, 86.6% of eligible men have been tested at least once since 1993. Cancer deaths in Tyrol in 2005 were 54% (95% confidence interval [CI] 34-69%) lower than expected compared with 29% (95% CI 22-35%) in the rest of Austria. The decreasing trend in prostate cancer mortality was significantly greater in Tyrol compared with the rest of Austria (P = 0.001). A significant migration to lower stage disease occurred and radical prostatectomy was associated with low morbidity.
In the Tyrol region where treatment is freely available to all patients, where widespread PSA testing and treatment with curative intent occurs, there was a reduction in prostate cancer mortality rates which was significantly greater than the reduction in the rest of Austria. This reduction in prostate cancer mortality is most probably due to early detection, consequent down-staging and effective treatment of prostate cancer.
评估奥地利蒂罗尔州一项控制良好的前列腺癌早期检测与治疗项目的效果。该州于1988年启动了这样一个早期检测与治疗项目,自1993年起为所有45至75岁的男性免费提供前列腺特异性抗原(PSA)检测。
通过广义相加模型比较蒂罗尔州和奥地利其他地区的前列腺癌死亡率。采用分段线性变化点泊松回归模型比较蒂罗尔州和奥地利其他地区的死亡率。以1986 - 1990年的死亡率为参考计算标准化死亡率。
自1993年以来,总计86.6%的符合条件男性至少接受过一次检测。与奥地利其他地区29%(95%置信区间[CI] 22 - 35%)相比,2005年蒂罗尔州的癌症死亡人数比预期低54%(95% CI 34 - 69%)。与奥地利其他地区相比,蒂罗尔州前列腺癌死亡率的下降趋势显著更大(P = 0.001)。出现了向低分期疾病的显著转移,根治性前列腺切除术的发病率较低。
在蒂罗尔地区,所有患者均可免费接受治疗,广泛开展了PSA检测且进行了根治性治疗,该地区前列腺癌死亡率的下降幅度显著大于奥地利其他地区。前列腺癌死亡率的这种下降很可能归因于早期检测、随之而来的分期降低以及前列腺癌的有效治疗。