Sabatelli L, Ghani A C, Rodrigues L C, Hotez P J, Brooker S
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Keppel Street, London, UK.
J R Soc Interface. 2008 Nov 6;5(28):1329-41. doi: 10.1098/rsif.2007.1255.
There is a growing emphasis on the development of vaccines against helminths (worms), and mathematical models provide a useful tool to assess the impact of new vaccines under a range of scenarios. The present study describes a stochastic individual-based model to assess the relative impact of chemotherapy and vaccination against human hookworm infection and investigates the implications of potential correlations between risk of infection and vaccine efficacy. Vaccination is simulated as a reduction in susceptibility to infection and the model includes population heterogeneities and dynamical waning of protection. To help identify appropriate measures of vaccine impact, we present a novel framework to quantify the vaccine impact on the infection-associated morbidity and introduce a measure of symmetry to study the correspondence between reduction in intensity and reduction in morbidity. Our modelling shows that, in high-transmission settings, the greatest impact of vaccination will be attained when vaccine efficacy is the greatest among individuals harbouring the heaviest worm burdens, and that the decline of morbidity primarily depends on the level of protection attained in the most at risk 8-12% of the population. We also demonstrate that if risk of infection and vaccine protection are correlated, there is not always a direct correspondence between the reduction in worm burden and in morbidity, with the precise relationship varying according to transmission setting.
人们越来越重视开发抗蠕虫疫苗,数学模型为评估新疫苗在一系列情况下的影响提供了有用工具。本研究描述了一种基于个体的随机模型,以评估化疗和疫苗接种对人类钩虫感染的相对影响,并研究感染风险与疫苗效力之间潜在相关性的影响。疫苗接种被模拟为感染易感性的降低,该模型包括人群异质性和保护作用的动态减弱。为了帮助确定衡量疫苗影响的适当指标,我们提出了一个新的框架来量化疫苗对感染相关发病率的影响,并引入了一种对称性指标来研究感染强度降低与发病率降低之间的对应关系。我们的模型显示,在高传播环境中,当疫苗效力在携带最重蠕虫负担的个体中最大时,疫苗接种将产生最大影响,发病率的下降主要取决于在最危险的8-12%人群中获得的保护水平。我们还证明,如果感染风险和疫苗保护相关,蠕虫负担的降低与发病率的降低之间并不总是直接对应,具体关系因传播环境而异。