Basić Baronica Koraljka, Sruk Ana, Planjar-Prvan Mljenka, Bielen Ivan
Neurology Department, Sveti Duh General Hospital, Zagreb, Croatia.
Acta Med Croatica. 2008 Feb;62(1):29-32.
According to literature data, the effect of seizures on inpatient mortality has not yet been not definitly determined and data on seizure incidence significantly vary with different methods used in various studies,
Our aim was to determine the effect of seizures in the peracute stage of stroke on inpatient mortality and to detect the possible association of seizure incidence and stroke subtype, age and sex.
Medical documentation of patients hospitalized at the ward for cerebrovascular diseases, Department of Neurology, Sveti Duh General Hospital from 1998 to 2005 was retrospectively analyzed. There were 3,542 patients with hemorrhagic or ischemic stroke. Seizures were defined as seizures occurring immediately before or within the first 24 hours of the neurological deficit development. Patients were subdivided into two groups, with and without seizures. Patients with a previous history of seizures were excluded from the study.
In a total of 3542 patients, there were 1885 (53.21%) male and 1657 (46.78%) female patients, mean age 70.06+11.03 in the non-seizure group and 67.93 +/- 13.02 in the seizure group. Seizures were significantly more frequent (p = 0.0002, OR 2.63) in patients with hemorrhagic stroke. Seizures were observed in 42 of 2931 (1.43%) patients with ischemic stroke and in 23 of 611 (3.76%) patients with hemorrhagic stroke. Total inpatient mortality was 21.4% in the group without seizures, and 30.8% in the group with seizures (p = 0.04). The ischemic stroke inpatient mortality in the seizure group was 19.5% (17.4% in non-seizure group), and hemorrhagic stroke inpatient mortality was 52.2% in the seizure group (41% in non-seizure group). There was no significant age and sex difference between the groups with and without seizures.
The rate of seizures has been estimated 1.7% to 8.9%. Different incidence rates are the result of different methods and different seizure definitions used in various studies. In our study seizures were significantly more frequent in patients with hemorrhagic stroke than in those with ischemic stroke, which is comparable to other studies. The slightly higher percentage of seizures reported in other studies is the result of the fact that they have analyzed seizures occurring from 48 hours to up to 30 days from stroke onset. The influence of seizures on inpatient mortality remains uncertain since different studies used different definitions of seizures and analyzed different stroke subtypes. Some studies found that seizures were associated with increased inpatient mortality; after accounting for stroke severity, population-based studies found no association between seizures and lethality. Our results support the conclusion that seizures cannot be taken as a prognostic factor in stroke.
The incidence of seizures during the first 24 hours of stroke onset was statistically significantly higher in patients with hemorrhagic stroke than in those with ischemic stroke. When all patients irrespective of stroke subtypes were analyzed, total inpatient mortality was statistically significantly higher in the seizure group. However, there was no statistically significant difference in inpatient mortality when ischemic and hemorrhagic groups were analyzed separately. There was no age and sex difference in the rate of seizures,
根据文献数据,癫痫发作对住院患者死亡率的影响尚未明确确定,并且不同研究中使用的不同方法使得癫痫发作发生率的数据差异很大。
我们的目的是确定中风急性期癫痫发作对住院患者死亡率的影响,并检测癫痫发作发生率与中风亚型、年龄和性别的可能关联。
回顾性分析了1998年至2005年在斯韦蒂杜赫综合医院神经内科脑血管疾病病房住院患者的医疗记录。共有3542例出血性或缺血性中风患者。癫痫发作定义为在神经功能缺损出现前或出现后的前24小时内发生的癫痫发作。患者被分为两组,有癫痫发作组和无癫痫发作组。有癫痫发作既往史的患者被排除在研究之外。
在总共3542例患者中,男性1885例(53.21%),女性1657例(46.78%),无癫痫发作组的平均年龄为70.06±11.03岁,癫痫发作组为67.93±13.02岁。出血性中风患者的癫痫发作明显更频繁(p = 0.0002,比值比2.63)。在2931例缺血性中风患者中有42例(1.43%)出现癫痫发作,在611例出血性中风患者中有23例(3.76%)出现癫痫发作。无癫痫发作组的总住院死亡率为21.4%,癫痫发作组为30.8%(p = 0.04)。癫痫发作组中缺血性中风的住院死亡率为19.5%(无癫痫发作组为17.4%),出血性中风在癫痫发作组中的住院死亡率为52.2%(无癫痫发作组为41%)。有癫痫发作组和无癫痫发作组之间在年龄和性别上没有显著差异。
癫痫发作率估计为1.7%至8.9%。不同的发生率是不同研究中使用不同方法和不同癫痫发作定义的结果。在我们的研究中,出血性中风患者的癫痫发作明显比缺血性中风患者更频繁,这与其他研究结果相当。其他研究中报告的癫痫发作百分比略高是因为他们分析了中风发作后48小时至30天内发生的癫痫发作。由于不同研究使用不同的癫痫发作定义并分析不同的中风亚型,癫痫发作对住院患者死亡率的影响仍然不确定。一些研究发现癫痫发作与住院患者死亡率增加有关;在考虑中风严重程度后,基于人群的研究发现癫痫发作与致死率之间没有关联。我们的结果支持癫痫发作不能作为中风预后因素的结论。
中风发作后前24小时内,出血性中风患者的癫痫发作发生率在统计学上显著高于缺血性中风患者。当分析所有患者(无论中风亚型)时,癫痫发作组的总住院死亡率在统计学上显著更高。然而,分别分析缺血性和出血性组时,住院死亡率没有统计学上的显著差异。癫痫发作率在年龄和性别上没有差异。