Boehmer Tegan K, Luke Douglas A, Haire-Joshu Debra L, Bates Hannalori S, Brownson Ross C
Saint Louis University School of Public Health, St. Louis, Missouri 63104, USA.
Am J Prev Med. 2008 Apr;34(4):333-40. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2008.01.003.
To address the epidemic of childhood obesity, health professionals are examining policies that address obesogenic environments; however, there has been little systematic examination of state legislative efforts in childhood obesity prevention. Using a policy research framework, this study sought to identify factors that predict successful enactment of childhood obesity prevention in all 50 states.
A legislative scan of bills introduced during 2003-2005 in all 50 states identified 717 bills related to childhood obesity prevention. Multilevel logistic regression modeling was performed in 2006 to identify bill-level (procedure, composition, and content) and state-level (sociodemographic, political, economic, and industrial) factors associated with bill enactment.
Seventeen percent of bills were enacted. Bill-level factors associated with increased likelihood of enactment included having more than one sponsor; bipartisan sponsorship; introduction in the state senate; budget proposals; and content areas related to safe routes to school, walking/biking trails, model school policies, statewide initiatives, and task forces and studies. State-level political factors, including 2-year legislative session and Democratic control of both chambers, increased enactment. An indicator of state socioeconomic status was inversely associated with bill enactment; economic and industrial variables were not significantly related to bill enactment.
In general, bill-level factors were more influential in their effect on policy enactment than state-level factors. This study provides policymakers, practitioners, and advocacy groups with strategies to develop more politically feasible childhood obesity prevention policies, including the identification of several modifiable bill characteristics that might improve bill enactment.
为应对儿童肥胖流行问题,卫生专业人员正在审视针对致肥环境的政策;然而,对于各州在预防儿童肥胖方面的立法努力,鲜有系统的审视。本研究运用政策研究框架,试图确定能预测在全美50个州成功颁布儿童肥胖预防政策的因素。
对2003 - 2005年期间全美50个州提出的法案进行立法审查,确定了717项与儿童肥胖预防相关的法案。2006年进行了多水平逻辑回归建模,以确定与法案颁布相关的法案层面(程序、组成和内容)和州层面(社会人口统计学、政治、经济和产业)因素。
17%的法案获得颁布。与颁布可能性增加相关的法案层面因素包括有不止一名提案人;两党共同提案;在州参议院提出;预算提案;以及与安全上学路线、步行/自行车道、示范学校政策、全州倡议、特别工作组和研究相关的内容领域。州层面的政治因素,包括两年制立法会议以及两院均由民主党控制,增加了法案的颁布。州社会经济地位指标与法案颁布呈负相关;经济和产业变量与法案颁布无显著关联。
总体而言,法案层面因素对政策颁布的影响比州层面因素更大。本研究为政策制定者、从业者和倡导团体提供了制定更具政治可行性的儿童肥胖预防政策的策略,包括确定一些可能提高法案颁布几率的可修改法案特征。