Bond Gary R, Drake Robert E, Becker Deborah R
Department of Psychology, Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, Indianapolis, IN 46202-3275, USA.
Psychiatr Rehabil J. 2008 Spring;31(4):280-90. doi: 10.2975/31.4.2008.280.290.
The Individual Placement and Support (IPS) model of supported employment for clients with severe mental illness has been described as a standardization of evidence-based supported employment. Although several reviews on the literature on its effectiveness have been conducted, the completion of several new studies suggests an updated review is warranted.
We conducted a comprehensive literature search for randomized controlled trials of IPS, limiting our review to programs with high-fidelity IPS programs, locating 11 studies. We examined the following competitive employment outcomes: employment rates, days to first job, annualized weeks worked, and job tenure in longest job held during the follow-up period.
Across the 11 studies, the competitive employment rate was 61% for IPS compared to 23% for controls. About two-thirds of those who obtained competitive employment worked 20 hours or more per week. Among those who obtained a competitive job, IPS participants obtained their first job nearly 10 weeks earlier than did controls. Among IPS participants who obtained competitive work, duration of employment after the start of the first job averaged 24.2 weeks per year, or 47% of the 52-week year.
The current review is consistent with earlier reviews, although the evidence for high-fidelity IPS appears to be somewhat stronger here than in reviews evaluating studies with more heterogeneity in the supported employment models examined. The number, consistency, and effect sizes of studies of evidence-based supported employment establish it as one of the most robust interventions available for persons with severe mental illness.
针对重度精神疾病患者的个体安置与支持(IPS)就业支持模式被描述为循证就业支持的标准化模式。尽管已经对其有效性的相关文献进行了几项综述,但几项新研究的完成表明有必要进行更新的综述。
我们对IPS的随机对照试验进行了全面的文献检索,将综述限制在具有高保真IPS项目的研究中,共找到11项研究。我们考察了以下竞争性就业成果:就业率、找到第一份工作的天数、年化工作周数以及随访期间最长工作的在职时长。
在这11项研究中,IPS的竞争性就业率为61%,而对照组为23%。在获得竞争性就业的人群中,约三分之二的人每周工作20小时或更长时间。在获得竞争性工作的人群中,IPS参与者比对照组提前近10周获得第一份工作。在获得竞争性工作的IPS参与者中,第一份工作开始后的就业时长平均每年为24.2周,即一年52周中的47%。
当前的综述与早期综述一致,尽管在此处高保真IPS的证据似乎比在评估支持就业模式中异质性更高的研究的综述中更强。循证就业支持研究的数量、一致性和效应量使其成为重度精神疾病患者可用的最有力干预措施之一。