Tan Lavinia, Grace Randolph C
University of Canterbury.
Sex Abuse. 2008 Mar;20(1):61-87. doi: 10.1177/1079063208314820.
Social desirability--the desire to make a favorable impression on others-poses a significant threat to the validity of self-reports. This review examines research on social desirability in both forensic and nonforensic populations with the goal of identifying how best to minimize threats to the validity of research with sexual offenders. Although social desirability has long been a major research topic in personality, consensus has not been reached on key questions such as its dimensional structure and whether social desirability constitutes a trait or a response bias. Research with offenders has shown that social desirability is negatively related to recidivism and that different offender subtypes vary in the degree to which social desirability appears to influence self-reports, with child molesters exhibiting the strongest tendency to "fake good." Several methods of controlling for social desirability have been proposed, but the effectiveness of these methods in increasing validity of offender self reports is questionable. Given the lack of consensus in the personality literature, a fresh start is needed in which basic questions regarding social desirability are revisited with respect to offender populations.
社会赞许性——即给他人留下良好印象的愿望——对自我报告的效度构成了重大威胁。本综述考察了法医群体和非法医群体中有关社会赞许性的研究,目的是确定如何最好地将对性犯罪者研究效度的威胁降至最低。尽管社会赞许性长期以来一直是人格研究中的一个主要课题,但在诸如其维度结构以及社会赞许性是构成一种特质还是一种反应偏差等关键问题上尚未达成共识。对犯罪者的研究表明,社会赞许性与再犯呈负相关,而且不同类型的犯罪者在社会赞许性似乎影响自我报告的程度上存在差异,其中恋童癖者表现出最强的“伪装良好”倾向。已经提出了几种控制社会赞许性的方法,但这些方法在提高犯罪者自我报告效度方面的有效性值得怀疑。鉴于人格文献中缺乏共识,需要重新开始,针对犯罪者群体重新审视有关社会赞许性的基本问题。