Meyer Thomas, Maier André, Borisow Nadja, Dullinger Jörn S, Splettstösser Gerald, Ohlraun Stephanie, Münch Christoph, Linke Peter
Dept. of Neurology, Charité University Hospital, Campus Virchow-Klinikum, Ambulanz für ALS und andere Motoneuronenerkrankungen, Augustenburger Platz 1, 13353 Berlin, Germany.
J Neurol. 2008 Apr;255(4):587-91. doi: 10.1007/s00415-008-0756-3. Epub 2008 Apr 21.
Neuroinflammation contributes to motor neuron degeneration in ALS. Thalidomide (THL) shows potent anti-inflammatory properties and increased the lifespan in ALS transgenic mice. Thalidomide was therefore suggested as atherapeutic intervention for the treatment of ALS.We conducted a pilot, randomized clinical trial of THL in patients with ALS to assess safety, feasibility, and preliminary estimates of treatment efficacy.
Patients were randomized to THL in combination with riluzole (n = 18) or riluzole alone (n = 19). THL was initiated at 100 mg per day for 6 weeks. Thereafter, the dose was increased every week by 50 mg until reaching the dose of 400 mg per day and planned to continue for another 12 weeks.
Within 12 weeks of THL treatment, nine THL patients (50%) developed bradycardia defined as a heart rate below 60 beats per minute (bpm) and ranged from 46 to 59 bpm. Mean heart rate dropped by 17 bpm with THL treatment. Severe symptomatic bradycardia of 30 bpm occurred in one patient. A further patient died from sudden unexpected death. The study was terminated prematurely for safety concerns. The secondary outcome variables showed similar results for both groups.
Bradycardia was the most common adverse event of THL treatment in ALS. THL-related bradycardia does not appear to be ALS-specific. It is conceivable, however, that the unexpected frequency and severity of THL-induced bradycardia may be related to subclinical involvement of the autonomic nervous system in ALS. The cardiac toxicity discourages further clinical trials and compassionate use of THL in ALS. ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT00231140.
神经炎症促成肌萎缩侧索硬化症(ALS)中运动神经元的退化。沙利度胺(THL)具有强大的抗炎特性,并能延长ALS转基因小鼠的寿命。因此,有人提出将沙利度胺作为治疗ALS的一种治疗性干预措施。我们开展了一项针对ALS患者的沙利度胺的试点随机临床试验,以评估安全性、可行性及治疗效果的初步估计。
患者被随机分为接受沙利度胺联合利鲁唑治疗组(n = 18)或单独接受利鲁唑治疗组(n = 19)。沙利度胺起始剂量为每日100毫克,持续6周。此后,剂量每周增加50毫克,直至达到每日400毫克的剂量,并计划继续服用12周。
在沙利度胺治疗的12周内,9名接受沙利度胺治疗的患者(50%)出现心动过缓,定义为心率低于每分钟60次(bpm),范围为46至59 bpm。接受沙利度胺治疗后平均心率下降了17 bpm。一名患者出现了严重的症状性心动过缓,心率为30 bpm。另有一名患者死于意外猝死。出于安全考虑,该研究提前终止。次要结局变量在两组中显示出相似的结果。
心动过缓是ALS患者接受沙利度胺治疗最常见的不良事件。与沙利度胺相关的心动过缓似乎并非ALS所特有。然而,可以想象,沙利度胺诱发心动过缓的意外频率和严重程度可能与ALS中自主神经系统的亚临床受累有关。心脏毒性不鼓励在ALS中进一步开展临床试验及同情用药。ClinicalTrials.gov标识符:NCT00231140。