Sawchuk Craig N, Charles Steve, Wen Yang, Goldberg Jack, Forquera Ralph, Roy-Byrne Peter, Buchwald Dedra
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98104, USA.
Prev Med. 2008 Jul;47(1):89-94. doi: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2008.03.011. Epub 2008 Mar 26.
Physical inactivity is common among older populations and American Indians. Our objective was to compare two methods for increasing physical activity and walking among American Indian elders.
We conducted a two arm randomized trial to increase physical activity in 125 American Indians aged 50-74 years at the Seattle Indian Health Board in 2005. Participants were randomized into either an activity monitoring (N=63) or activity monitoring with a pedometer (N=62) arm over a six-week period. Outcomes included self-reported physical activity and well-being, and the 6-min walk test.
There were no group differences in self-reported physical activities and well-being. The 6-min walk test yielded no between-group differences. All participants increased the frequency of leisure walking (p<0.01), frequency of all exercise-related activities (p<0.01), frequency of moderate-intensity exercise activities (p<0.01), and improved weekly caloric expenditure for all exercise activities (p<0.05) by the end of the trial.
Pedometers did not confer enhanced performance on the physical activity outcomes beyond those achieved through self-monitoring. Physical activity can be promoted among at-risk groups in a brief, inexpensive manner in primary care. Exercise prescription and culturally relevant enhancement strategies may optimize physical activity outcomes for elder American Indians.
身体活动不足在老年人群和美国印第安人中很常见。我们的目的是比较两种增加美国印第安老年人身体活动和步行量的方法。
2005年,我们在西雅图印第安人健康委员会对125名年龄在50 - 74岁的美国印第安人进行了一项双臂随机试验,以增加他们的身体活动量。参与者在六周的时间里被随机分为活动监测组(N = 63)或佩戴计步器的活动监测组(N = 62)。结果包括自我报告的身体活动和幸福感,以及6分钟步行测试。
在自我报告的身体活动和幸福感方面,两组之间没有差异。6分钟步行测试在组间也没有差异。到试验结束时,所有参与者的休闲步行频率(p < 0.01)、所有与运动相关活动的频率(p < 0.01)、中等强度运动活动的频率(p < 0.01)均有所增加,并且所有运动活动的每周热量消耗也有所改善(p < 0.05)。
计步器在身体活动结果方面并没有比通过自我监测获得的结果有更好的表现。在初级保健中,可以以一种简短、廉价的方式在高危人群中促进身体活动。运动处方和与文化相关的强化策略可能会优化美国印第安老年人的身体活动结果。