Smith Gerard P
Department of Psychiatry, Weill Cornell Medical College, Payne Whitney Westchester, New York Presbyterian Hospital, White Plains, NY 10605, USA.
Appetite. 2008 Nov;51(3):428-32. doi: 10.1016/j.appet.2008.07.003. Epub 2008 Jul 12.
Cannon's theory of homeostasis is the first, major, American contribution to physiological thought. Although it is clear that Cannon's account of homeostasis is personal and based primarily on the work of his laboratory, Cannon made it easy for readers to mistake his 1929 paper and 1932 book for a comprehensive review of the literature relevant to homeostasis. This is unfortunate because Cannon never acknowledged the important contributions of two of his contemporaries, Ivan Pavlov and Joseph Barcroft. Since he did not mention them, their contributions are rarely discussed. This paper attempts to correct this historical problem in two ways. First, I describe the unacknowledged contributions of Pavlov and Barcroft. Then I consider the possible reasons why Cannon ignored them.
坎农的稳态理论是美国对生理学思想的首个重要贡献。尽管很明显坎农对稳态的阐述是个人观点且主要基于其实验室的工作,但坎农使读者很容易将他1929年的论文和1932年的著作误认为是对与稳态相关文献的全面综述。这很不幸,因为坎农从未承认过他的两位同时代人伊万·巴甫洛夫和约瑟夫·巴克罗夫特的重要贡献。由于他没有提及他们,所以他们的贡献很少被讨论。本文试图通过两种方式纠正这一历史问题。首先,我描述巴甫洛夫和巴克罗夫特未被承认的贡献。然后我思考坎农忽视他们的可能原因。