Devine-Wright Hannah, Devine-Wright Patrick
Manchester Architecture Research Centre, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Br J Soc Psychol. 2009 Jun;48(Pt 2):357-73. doi: 10.1348/014466608X349504. Epub 2008 Sep 11.
The aim of this study was to explore everyday thinking about the UK electricity network, in light of government policy to increase the generation of electricity from renewable energy sources. Existing literature on public perceptions of electricity network technologies was broadened by adopting a more socially embedded conception of the construction of knowledge using the theory of social representations (SRT) to explore symbolic associations with network technologies. Drawing and association tasks were administered within nine discussion groups held in two places: a Scottish town where significant upgrades to the local transmission network were planned and an English city with no such plans. Our results illustrate the ways in which network technologies, such as high voltage (HV) pylons, are objectified in talk and drawings. These invoked positive as well as negative symbolic and affective associations, both at the level of specific pylons, and the 'National Grid' as a whole and are anchored in understanding of other networks such as mobile telecommunications. We conclude that visual methods are especially useful for exploring beliefs about technologies that are widespread, proximal to our everyday experience but nevertheless unfamiliar topics of everyday conversation.
本研究的目的是,鉴于政府增加可再生能源发电的政策,探讨公众对英国电网的日常看法。通过运用社会表征理论(SRT)采用一种更具社会嵌入性的知识建构概念,来拓展现有关于公众对电网技术认知的文献,以探究与电网技术的象征性关联。在两个地方举行的九个讨论小组中开展了绘图和联想任务:一个是计划对当地输电网络进行重大升级的苏格兰城镇,另一个是没有此类计划的英格兰城市。我们的研究结果说明了高压(HV)输电塔等电网技术在谈话和绘图中是如何被客观化的。这些在特定输电塔层面以及整个“国家电网”层面都引发了积极和消极的象征性及情感性联想,并且这些联想基于对诸如移动电信等其他网络的理解。我们得出结论,视觉方法对于探究关于广泛存在、与我们日常经验相近但仍是日常谈话中不熟悉话题的技术的信念特别有用。