Komase Yuko, Abe Tadashi, Kasahara Keita, Kaneko Takeshi, Takahashi Hiroshi, Nishikawa Masanori, Kuwahira Ichiro
St. Marianna University School of Medicine, Yokohama-City Seibu Hospital, Yokohama.
Intern Med. 2008;47(20):1791-6. doi: 10.2169/internalmedicine.47.1006. Epub 2008 Oct 15.
Since mild COPD can be detected in the annual health check by lung function tests, we conducted a questionnaire survey on how such examinations are used to assess chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
We mailed questionnaires to 633 facilities performing comprehensive medical check-up from June to July 2005 and obtained responses from 254 (40.1%).
At participating facilities, the proportion of full or part-time physicians specializing in respiratory diseases was low [40 of 366 full timers (10.9%) and 114 of 2,044 part-timers (5.6%)], with very few physicians certified by the Japanese Respiratory Society (6.8%). Non respiratory physicians were involved in evaluating the results of thoracic diagnostic imaging at 32 facilities. Lung function tests were carried out at 98.2% of facilities though relatively few facilities evaluated test results with COPD in mind. All stages (mild, moderate, severe) of COPD were diagnosed in patients at 85 facilities (39.2%), while only severe COPD was targeted by chest imaging at 97 facilities (44.7%), disregarding mild and moderate cases. Counseling for smoking cessation was provided at 113 facilities (20.6%), while 30 facilities (14.4%) provided no form of smoking cessation.
At most facilities performing a comprehensive medical check-up, there was not a sufficient number of respirologists to ensure early diagnosis of COPD and this may have compromised COPD diagnosis. The newly proposed Japan Society of Comprehensive Medical Check-up (Ningen-dock) Standards based on the Japanese Respiratory Society may be useful to reveal early stages of COPD.
鉴于轻度慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)可通过年度健康检查中的肺功能测试检测出来,我们针对此类检查如何用于评估慢性阻塞性肺疾病展开了一项问卷调查。
2005年6月至7月,我们向633家开展综合体检的机构邮寄了问卷,收到254份回复(40.1%)。
在参与调查的机构中,专职或兼职的呼吸内科专科医生比例较低[366名全职医生中有40名(10.9%),2044名兼职医生中有114名(5.6%)],获得日本呼吸学会认证的医生极少(6.8%)。32家机构有非呼吸内科医生参与评估胸部诊断成像结果。98.2%的机构开展了肺功能测试,但考虑到COPD来评估测试结果的机构相对较少。85家机构(39.2%)诊断出了各阶段(轻度、中度、重度)的COPD患者,而97家机构(44.7%)仅通过胸部成像针对重度COPD进行检查,忽略了轻度和中度病例。113家机构(20.6%)提供了戒烟咨询,30家机构(14.4%)未提供任何形式的戒烟服务。
在大多数开展综合体检的机构中,呼吸科医生数量不足,无法确保COPD的早期诊断,这可能影响了COPD的诊断。基于日本呼吸学会新提出的日本综合体检协会(Ningen-dock)标准可能有助于发现COPD的早期阶段。