Naue Ursula, Kroll Thilo
Department of Political Science, University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Nurs Philos. 2009 Jan;10(1):26-33. doi: 10.1111/j.1466-769X.2008.00379.x.
This paper explores the impact of the concepts of identity and difference on demented persons (especially on persons with Alzheimer's disease). The diagnosis of dementia is often synonymous with the assertion that demented individuals are no longer capable of making reasonable decisions. But rationality is an important aspect of characterizing a person's identity. Hence, this prevailing image of dementia as a loss of self and a change of identity leads to the situation that demented persons represent difference and otherness. Here, the brain and the mind act as the source for difference. The paper discusses several identity concepts with regard to demented persons and the relationship between identity and difference in dementia. This analysis is accompanied by an examination of the current biopolitics of dementia and ageing as biopolitics constitutes the socio-political-medical understanding of dementia. Challenges and possibilities for dementia care will be explored in the context of this complex relationship between theoretical concepts and political, medical, and health-care practices.
本文探讨身份认同和差异概念对患有痴呆症的人(尤其是阿尔茨海默病患者)的影响。痴呆症的诊断常常等同于宣称患有痴呆症的个体不再有能力做出合理决策。但理性是界定一个人身份的重要方面。因此,这种将痴呆症普遍视为自我丧失和身份改变的观念导致了患有痴呆症的人被视为差异和他者的情况。在这里,大脑和心智成为差异的根源。本文讨论了几个与患有痴呆症的人相关的身份概念,以及痴呆症中身份认同与差异之间的关系。这种分析伴随着对当前痴呆症和老龄化生物政治学的审视,因为生物政治学构成了对痴呆症的社会 - 政治 - 医学理解。在理论概念与政治、医学及医疗保健实践之间这种复杂关系的背景下,将探讨痴呆症护理面临的挑战和可能性。