Lin Jin-Mann S, Brimmer Dana J, Boneva Roumiana S, Jones James F, Reeves William C
Chronic Viral Diseases Branch, National Center for Zoonotic, Vector-Borne and Enteric Diseases, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA 30333, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2009 Jan 20;9:13. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-9-13.
The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence of barriers to healthcare utilization in persons with fatiguing illness and describe its association with socio-demographics, the number of health conditions, and frequency of healthcare utilization. Furthermore, we sought to identify what types of barriers interfered with healthcare utilization and why they occurred.
In a cross-sectional population-based survey, 780 subjects, 112 of them with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), completed a healthcare utilization questionnaire. Text analysis was used to create the emerging themes from verbatim responses regarding barriers to healthcare utilization. Multiple logistic regression was performed to examine the association between barriers to healthcare utilization and other factors.
Forty percent of subjects reported at least one barrier to healthcare utilization. Of 112 subjects with CFS, 55% reported at least one barrier to healthcare utilization. Fatiguing status, reported duration of fatigue, insurance, and BMI were significant risk factors for barriers to healthcare utilization. After adjusting for socio-demographics, medication use, the number of health problems, and frequency of healthcare utilization, fatiguing status remained significantly associated with barriers to healthcare utilization. Subjects with CFS were nearly 4 times more likely to forego needed healthcare during the preceding year than non-fatigued subjects while those with insufficient fatigue (ISF) were nearly 3 times more likely.Three domains emerged from text analysis on barriers to healthcare utilization: 1) accessibility; 2) knowledge-attitudes-beliefs (KABs); and, 3) healthcare system. CFS and reported duration of fatigue were significantly associated with each of these domains. Persons with CFS reported high levels of healthcare utilization barriers for each domain: accessibility (34%), healthcare system (25%), and KABs (19%). In further examination of barrier domains to healthcare utilization, compared to non-fatigued persons adjusted ORs for CFS having "accessibility", "KAB" and "Healthcare System" barrier domains decreased by 40%, 30%, and 19%, respectively.
Barriers to healthcare utilization pose a significant problem in persons with fatiguing illnesses. Study results suggested two-fold implications: a symptom-targeted model focusing on symptoms associated with fatigue; and an interactive model requiring efforts from patients and providers to improve interactions between them by reducing barriers in accessibility, KABs, and healthcare system.
本研究旨在确定疲劳性疾病患者医疗服务利用障碍的患病率,并描述其与社会人口统计学、健康状况数量以及医疗服务利用频率之间的关联。此外,我们试图确定哪些类型的障碍会干扰医疗服务利用以及它们产生的原因。
在一项基于人群的横断面调查中,780名受试者(其中112名患有慢性疲劳综合征(CFS))完成了一份医疗服务利用问卷。文本分析用于从关于医疗服务利用障碍的逐字回复中提炼出新兴主题。进行多因素逻辑回归以检验医疗服务利用障碍与其他因素之间的关联。
40%的受试者报告至少存在一项医疗服务利用障碍。在112名CFS患者中,55%报告至少存在一项医疗服务利用障碍。疲劳状态、报告的疲劳持续时间、保险和体重指数是医疗服务利用障碍的显著危险因素。在对社会人口统计学、药物使用、健康问题数量和医疗服务利用频率进行调整后,疲劳状态仍然与医疗服务利用障碍显著相关。与无疲劳的受试者相比,CFS患者在前一年放弃必要医疗服务的可能性几乎是非疲劳受试者的4倍,而疲劳不足(ISF)的患者则几乎是3倍。医疗服务利用障碍的文本分析产生了三个领域:1)可及性;2)知识 - 态度 - 信念(KABs);3)医疗系统。CFS和报告的疲劳持续时间与这些领域中的每一个都显著相关。CFS患者在每个领域都报告了较高水平的医疗服务利用障碍:可及性(34%)、医疗系统(25%)和KABs(19%)。在对医疗服务利用障碍领域的进一步研究中,与无疲劳的人相比,CFS患者在“可及性”、“KAB”和“医疗系统”障碍领域的调整后比值比分别下降了40%、30%和19%。
医疗服务利用障碍在疲劳性疾病患者中构成了一个重大问题。研究结果表明有两方面的意义:一个是以症状为导向的模型,侧重于与疲劳相关的症状;另一个是互动模型,要求患者和提供者共同努力,通过减少可及性、KABs和医疗系统方面的障碍来改善他们之间的互动。