Irita Kazuo, Inada Eiichi, Yoshimura Hayashi, Warabi Kengo, Tsuzaki Koichi, Inaba Shoichi, Handa Makoto, Uemura Tomoe, Kino Shuichi, Mashiko Kunihiro, Yano Tetsu, Kamei Yoshimasa, Kubo Takahiko
Office for the New Hospital Construction, Kyushu University Hospital, Fukuoka 812-8582.
Masui. 2009 Jan;58(1):109-23.
Annual surveys conducted by the Japanese Society of Anesthesiologists repeatedly show that hemorrhage is the leading cause of life-threatening events in the operating room.
We performed a questionnaire survey regarding the present status of critical hemorrhage/ blood transfusion occurring in the operating room on an institutional scale and individual blood transfusion management in cases of massive hemorrhage (> or = 5,000 ml) in hospitals with > or = 500 beds and those with an accredited Department of Anesthesiology regarded as regional hospitals.
Of 384 institutions, 247 responded to the questionnaire (response rate: 64%), and 692,241 cases managed by anesthesiologists in 2006 were registered. There were 2,657 cases of massive hemorrhage above the circulating blood volume in the operating room, and 404 of them were critical. Thus, the number of cases of massive hemorrhage was 6.6 times that of cases of critical events due to hemorrhage. In the survey of individual cases of massive hemorrhage (> or = 5,000 ml), 1,257 cases were registered in 2006, of whom 196 cases (15.6%) died within 30 post-operative days and 160 cases (12.7%) had some sequelae. The amount of transfused red blood cell concentrate was 25.2 +/- 24.2 units. The amount of red blood cell concentrates stocked for emergency was 12.7 +/- 10.1 units for blood group A, 9.7 +/- 7.3 units for group B, 11.9 +/- 9.6 group AB, and 11.3 +/- 11.0 for group O. Therefore, for those other than group O cases, 21-46 units of red blood cell concentrates seemed to be available in the hospital. The survey of individual cases showed uncross-matched, same blood group transfusion and compatible, different blood group transfusion were performed in only 8.2% and 4.3%, respectively. The lowest hemoglobin concentration was below 5 g x dl(-1) in 16.7% of the cases, but uncross-matched, same blood group transfusion was performed only in 19.0% and compatible, different blood group red cell concentrate transfusion in 5.2%. Even in cases who required cardiac massage, uncross-matched, same blood group transfusion was performed only in 17.1% and compatible, different blood group red cell concentrate transfusion in 8.5%. Intraoperative blood salvage was performed in only 5.7% in cases who underwent non-cardiac surgery. The "Guidelines for the Management of Critical Hemorrhage" proposed in 2007 or the manuals for in-hospital emergency blood transfusion were insufficiently recognized, even by anesthesiologists, and rarely known by surgeons. There were no such manuals in more than 60% of the institutions.
Undertransfusion may occur in 16.7-28.3% of cases of massive hemorrhage in the operating room, and the rate of emergency blood transfusion was much lower than this percentage. To avoid operation-associated deaths from hemorrhage, the improvement of hospital systems for emergency blood transfusion, including the active use of intraoperative blood salvage, should be promoted.
日本麻醉医师协会进行的年度调查反复表明,出血是手术室危及生命事件的主要原因。
我们在机构层面就手术室发生的严重出血/输血现状以及床位≥500张且设有经认可的麻醉科(被视为地区医院)的医院中大量出血(≥5000毫升)病例的个体输血管理进行了问卷调查。
在384家机构中,247家回复了问卷(回复率:64%),并登记了2006年麻醉医师管理的692241例病例。手术室中有2657例出血超过循环血量的大量出血病例,其中404例为严重出血。因此,大量出血病例数是出血导致的危急事件病例数的6.6倍。在对大量出血(≥5000毫升)个体病例的调查中,2006年登记了1257例,其中196例(15.6%)在术后30天内死亡,160例(12.7%)有一些后遗症。输注的红细胞浓缩液量为25.2±24.2单位。用于紧急情况的红细胞浓缩液储备量,A型血为12.7±10.1单位,B型血为9.7±7.3单位,AB型血为11.9±9.6单位,O型血为11.3±11.0单位。因此,除O型血病例外,医院似乎有21 - 46单位的红细胞浓缩液可用。个体病例调查显示,未交叉配血的同型输血和相容的异型输血分别仅占8.2%和4.3%。最低血红蛋白浓度在16.7%的病例中低于5克/分升,但未交叉配血的同型输血仅占19.0%,相容的异型红细胞浓缩液输血占5.2%。即使在需要心脏按压的病例中,未交叉配血的同型输血仅占17.1%,相容的异型红细胞浓缩液输血占8.5%。非心脏手术病例中仅5.7%进行了术中血液回收。2007年提出的《严重出血管理指南》或医院内紧急输血手册,即使麻醉医师也认识不足,外科医师很少知晓。超过六成的机构没有此类手册。
手术室大量出血病例中16.7% - 28.3%可能存在输血不足情况,紧急输血率远低于该百分比。为避免手术相关的出血死亡,应推动完善医院紧急输血系统,包括积极使用术中血液回收。