Evans Katharine S E, North Rachel V, Purslow Christine
Contact Lens and Anterior Eye Research (CLAER) Unit, School of Optometry and Vision Sciences, Cardiff University, Maindy Road, Cardiff, UK.
Ophthalmic Physiol Opt. 2009 Mar;29(2):199-204. doi: 10.1111/j.1475-1313.2008.00626.x.
Tear ferning (TF) has shown good sensitivity and specificity in the diagnosis of dry eye, but is a relatively uncommon test, especially in contact lens wearers. The aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between TF, ocular comfort and tear film stability amongst contact lens (CL) wearers and non-contact lens (NCL) wearers. Subjects (36 NCL, 24 CL; mean age 23.2 +/- 4.8 years) underwent assessment of non-invasive tear break up time (NIBUT), fluorescein tear break up time (FBUT) and completed the Ocular Comfort Index (OCI) questionnaire. Non-stimulated tears were collected from the inferior tear meniscus with a glass capillary. Samples of 1.5 microL were air dried, observed by light microscopy and the TF pattern quantified according to Rolando's grading scale. Significantly higher grades of TF pattern and discomfort (higher OCI scores) were observed in CL wearers compared to NCL wearers (Mann-Whitney U-test; p < 0.005 and p < 0.05 respectively). Differences in tear film stability were not significant between groups. Even when asymptomatic (low OCI scores) CL and NCL subjects were compared, TF remained significantly different (p < 0.005). In both CL and NCL subjects, TF displayed poor correlation with tear film stability tests and OCI scores. Higher TF grades in CL wearers, even if asymptomatic, indicate an unfavourable ratio of salt to macromolecule concentration within the tear film of such subjects. The lack of significant difference in TF between symptomatic CL and NCL wearers could suggest similar aetiology (tear film hyperosmolarity) in each cohort. The TF technique demonstrates limited sensitivity and specificity for the prediction of ocular surface comfort in both CL and NCL wearers.
泪液蕨样变(TF)在干眼诊断中显示出良好的敏感性和特异性,但它是一种相对不常见的检查,尤其是在隐形眼镜佩戴者中。本研究的目的是调查隐形眼镜(CL)佩戴者和非隐形眼镜(NCL)佩戴者中TF、眼部舒适度和泪膜稳定性之间的关系。受试者(36名NCL佩戴者、24名CL佩戴者;平均年龄23.2±4.8岁)接受了无创泪膜破裂时间(NIBUT)、荧光素泪膜破裂时间(FBUT)的评估,并完成了眼部舒适度指数(OCI)问卷。用玻璃毛细管从下泪液弯月面收集未受刺激的泪液。将1.5微升的样本进行空气干燥,通过光学显微镜观察,并根据罗兰多分级量表对TF模式进行量化。与NCL佩戴者相比,CL佩戴者的TF模式分级和不适感(OCI得分更高)显著更高(曼-惠特尼U检验;分别为p<0.005和p<0.05)。两组之间泪膜稳定性的差异不显著。即使比较无症状(OCI得分低)的CL和NCL受试者,TF仍然有显著差异(p<0.005)。在CL和NCL受试者中,TF与泪膜稳定性测试和OCI得分的相关性都很差。CL佩戴者中较高的TF分级,即使无症状,也表明这些受试者泪膜中盐与大分子浓度的比例不利。有症状的CL和NCL佩戴者之间TF缺乏显著差异可能表明每个队列中有相似的病因(泪膜高渗)。TF技术在预测CL和NCL佩戴者的眼表舒适度方面显示出有限的敏感性和特异性。