Nelson-Wong Erika, Flynn Timothy, Callaghan Jack P
Department of Kinesiology, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON, Canada.
J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2009 Sep;39(9):649-57. doi: 10.2519/jospt.2009.3093.
Analytic observational prospective study performed in a controlled laboratory setting.
To assess the ability of a new screening tool, the active hip abduction test, to predict low back pain development during prolonged standing in previously asymptomatic individuals.
Most screening tools used for a patient with low back pain do not assess the patient's ability to maintain postural control in the frontal plane, when placed in an unstable position. Postural-control differences in pain developers, as compared to non-pain developers, during standing have been found previously. An attempt was made to predict pain development with a simple screening test.
Forty-three previously asymptomatic volunteers underwent a clinical assessment prior to a 2-hour standing protocol designed to induce low back pain. Participants rated low back pain with a visual analog scale and were classified into pain developers or non-pain developers.
Forty percent of participants developed low back pain. The active hip abduction test was the only test that discriminated between pain-developer groups. When the examiner scored the test, the odds ratio was 3.85 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.05-19.07), and when the test was self-rated, the odds ratio was 6.55 (95% CI: 1.14-37.75) for pain development during standing.
The active hip abduction test appears to show promise for predicting individuals who are at risk for low back pain development during prolonged standing. More work is required to validate the test in clinical populations, and to assess interrater and intrarater reliability.
在受控实验室环境中进行的分析性观察前瞻性研究。
评估一种新的筛查工具——主动髋关节外展试验,预测既往无症状个体在长时间站立过程中发生腰痛的能力。
大多数用于腰痛患者的筛查工具并未评估患者在处于不稳定姿势时在额状面维持姿势控制的能力。先前已发现疼痛发生者与未发生疼痛者在站立时姿势控制存在差异。曾尝试通过一项简单的筛查试验预测疼痛的发生。
43名既往无症状的志愿者在一项旨在诱发腰痛的2小时站立试验前接受了临床评估。参与者用视觉模拟量表对腰痛进行评分,并被分为疼痛发生者或未发生疼痛者。
40%的参与者发生了腰痛。主动髋关节外展试验是唯一能区分疼痛发生组的试验。当由检查者对试验进行评分时,站立时疼痛发生的比值比为3.85(95%置信区间[CI]:1.05 - 19.07),当试验为自我评分时,比值比为6.55(95%CI:1.14 - 37.75)。
主动髋关节外展试验似乎有望预测长时间站立过程中发生腰痛风险的个体。需要开展更多工作以在临床人群中验证该试验,并评估检查者间和检查者内的可靠性。