Clark Melissa A, Rogers Michelle L, Wen Xiaozhong, Wilcox Victoria, McCarthy-Barnett Kate, Panarace Jeanne, Manning Carol, Allen Susan, Rakowski William
Departmentsof Community Health, Brown University Warren Alpert School of Medicine and Program in Public Health, Providence, Rhode Island 02912, USA.
Womens Health Issues. 2009 Nov-Dec;19(6):415-24. doi: 10.1016/j.whi.2009.08.001. Epub 2009 Sep 23.
Unmarried women with disabilities may be a particularly vulnerable group for underutilization of repeat mammography screening. Our goal was to compare the breast cancer screening experiences of unmarried women with disabilities (WWD) versus women with no disabilities (WND), and determine whether these experiences are associated with adherence to repeat screening.
We conducted a matched cohort study of 93 WWD and 93 WND to compare mammography experiences by disability status, examine rates of repeat mammography by disability status, and identify factors that are associated with repeat mammography.
WWD were less likely to be on-schedule than WND in univariable (54.8% vs. 71.0%; relative risk, 0.77; 95% confidence limits, 0.61, 0.97), but not multivariable, analyses. In multivariable analyses, there was a significant interaction between disability status and positive experiences as the reasons for returning to the same mammography facility. Among WND, repeat screening ranged from 59% to 86%, depending on the number of positive experiences endorsed (range, 1-5). In contrast, among WWD, screening rates were only 37% among those who did not report any positive experiences and increased to a maximum of 60% regardless of whether women endorsed one to four or all five positive experiences. Severity and type of disability were not associated with repeat screening.
WWD may be less likely than WND to remain on-schedule for mammography. WWD who do not report any positive experiences as reasons for returning to a mammography facility may be at particularly high risk of underutilization of screening.
未婚残疾女性可能是重复乳腺钼靶筛查利用不足的特别弱势群体。我们的目标是比较未婚残疾女性(WWD)与非残疾女性(WND)的乳腺癌筛查经历,并确定这些经历是否与重复筛查的依从性相关。
我们对93名WWD和93名WND进行了一项匹配队列研究,以比较不同残疾状况下的钼靶检查经历,按残疾状况检查重复钼靶检查率,并确定与重复钼靶检查相关的因素。
在单变量分析中,WWD按时进行筛查的可能性低于WND(54.8%对71.0%;相对风险,0.77;95%置信区间,0.61,0.97),但在多变量分析中并非如此。在多变量分析中,残疾状况与作为返回同一钼靶检查机构原因的积极经历之间存在显著交互作用。在WND中,根据认可的积极经历数量(范围为1 - 5),重复筛查率在59%至86%之间。相比之下,在WWD中,未报告任何积极经历的女性筛查率仅为37%,无论女性认可一至四项还是全部五项积极经历,筛查率最高增至60%。残疾的严重程度和类型与重复筛查无关。
WWD按时进行钼靶检查的可能性可能低于WND。未将任何积极经历报告为返回钼靶检查机构原因的WWD可能处于筛查利用不足的特别高风险中。