Medical University of South Carolina Medical Center and College of Pharmacy, Charleston, SC 29425, USA.
Respir Med. 2010 May;104(5):717-23. doi: 10.1016/j.rmed.2009.12.009. Epub 2010 Jan 20.
Most issues concerning pharmacotherapy of pulmonary sarcoidosis have not been resolved in clinical trials. The objective was to survey sarcoidosis experts concerning the treatment of pulmonary sarcoidosis and attempt to reach a consensus by these experts using a Delphi method.
A 6-item questionnaire was developed. Experts were identified at the Diffuse Lung Disease Network at the annual CHEST meeting in October 2008. Three rounds of questionnaires were presented to the experts. Respondent feedback and supporting literature was incorporated into the questionnaires of subsequent rounds.
Experts reached a consensus concerning the following issues: (a) corticosteroids are the initial therapy of choice; (b) initial use of inhaled corticosteroids are not recommended; (c) methotrexate was the preferred second-line drug; (d) 40mg of daily prednisone equivalent was the maximum dose recommended for the treatment of acute pulmonary sarcoidosis; (e) tapering to 10mg of daily prednisone equivalent for chronic pulmonary sarcoidosis was considered a successful taper. The experts could not resolve the following issues: (a) the initial corticosteroid dose for the treatment of acute pulmonary sarcoidosis; (b) the decision and timing of corticosteroid therapy in a patient with mild, Stage 2 pulmonary sarcoidosis.
This Delphi study revealed that sarcoidosis experts reached a consensus concerning several aspects of the treatment of pulmonary sarcoidosis; these could be considered as appropriate approaches to therapy. Other issues concerning the therapy of pulmonary sarcoidosis remain unresolved by experts, and are areas where further clinical research could be directed.
大多数关于肺结节病药物治疗的问题在临床试验中都没有得到解决。目的是调查结节病专家对肺结节病的治疗方法,并尝试通过德尔菲法让这些专家达成共识。
制定了一份 6 项问题的调查问卷。在 2008 年 10 月 CHEST 年会上的弥漫性肺病网络会议上确定了专家人选。向专家进行了三轮问卷调查。将受访者的反馈和支持文献纳入后续轮次的问卷中。
专家们就以下问题达成了共识:(a)皮质类固醇是首选的初始治疗方法;(b)不建议初始使用吸入皮质类固醇;(c)甲氨蝶呤是首选的二线药物;(d)每日 40mg 泼尼松等效剂量是治疗急性肺结节病的最大推荐剂量;(e)慢性肺结节病减至每日 10mg 泼尼松等效剂量被认为是成功的减量。专家们无法解决以下问题:(a)治疗急性肺结节病的初始皮质类固醇剂量;(b)轻度、2 期肺结节病患者皮质类固醇治疗的决策和时机。
这项德尔菲研究表明,结节病专家就肺结节病治疗的几个方面达成了共识;这些可以被认为是适当的治疗方法。其他关于肺结节病治疗的问题仍未得到专家解决,这是进一步临床研究可以关注的领域。