Øien Aud Marie, Steihaug Sissel, Iversen Synnøve, Råheim Målfrid
Department of Public Health and Primary Health Care, Section of Physiotherapy Science, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
Scand J Caring Sci. 2011 Mar;25(1):53-61. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-6712.2010.00790.x.
The purpose of this study was to describe communicative patterns about change in demanding physiotherapy treatment situations.
A multiple case study of eleven treatment courses was carried out, based on in-depth individual interviews, focus group interview, personal notes and repeated video-recordings. To compare communication within and over sessions, a two-step procedure was applied: identification of communication patterns and detailed analysis of selected dialogues from video-recorded sequences.
One main communicative pattern was identified: Seeking for common ground--demanding negotiating process. This pattern was interrupted by short episodes of two types of challenges; the pattern of ambivalence and uncertainty, and the pattern of impatience and disagreement. Communication between the participants appeared as a demanding and complex process of negotiations during the treatment processes. The physiotherapists' sensitivity of and ability to negotiate the tasks, the emotions related to tasks and the nature of the relationships, seemed to facilitate change. The patients' and the physiotherapists' capacity to bear and come through demanding situations created new ways of interaction.
The demanding situations may generate a potential for the development and the improvement of treatment outcomes. Understanding such episodes as open and dynamic, in contrast to defining the patient as demanding, suggests a useful perspective for treatment.
本研究旨在描述在要求进行物理治疗的情况下有关变化的沟通模式。
基于深入的个人访谈、焦点小组访谈、个人笔记和反复录像,对11个治疗疗程进行了多案例研究。为了比较各疗程内及不同疗程间的沟通情况,采用了两步法:识别沟通模式并对录像片段中选定的对话进行详细分析。
确定了一种主要的沟通模式:寻求共同点——要求进行谈判的过程。这种模式被两种类型的挑战的短片段打断;矛盾与不确定模式,以及不耐烦与分歧模式。在治疗过程中,参与者之间的沟通表现为一个要求苛刻且复杂的谈判过程。物理治疗师对任务进行谈判的敏感性和能力、与任务相关的情绪以及关系的性质,似乎有助于改变。患者和物理治疗师承受并度过要求苛刻情况的能力创造了新的互动方式。
要求苛刻的情况可能为治疗结果的发展和改善创造潜力。将此类情况理解为开放和动态的,而不是将患者定义为要求苛刻,这为治疗提供了一个有用的视角。