Deli Tamás, Szeverényi Péter
Debreceni Egyetem, Orvos- es Egészségtudományi Centrum, Szülészeti es Nogyógyászati Klinika Debrecen.
Orv Hetil. 2010 Apr 25;151(17):702-6. doi: 10.1556/OH.2010.28833.
The human fetus can suffer several presumably painful interventions perinatally and even before, during its intrauterine life. In the past years, scientific dispute concerning the existence of fetal pain and the need for its relief has expanded, and a heated social, political, religious, moral and philosophical debate has arisen, focusing mainly on the suffering experienced by the fetus during artificial abortion. In our two connected papers, medical scientific knowledge regarding fetal pain in the literature is reviewed. In the first article published in Orvosi Hetilap volume 150, issue 11, we defined pain and the neuroanatomical structures participating in subjective pain perception, as well as the development of these structures. Then, the objective indicators of intrauterine stress response (such as fetal neuroendocrine, cardiovascular, reflex and behavioral reactions) evoked by noxious stimuli were discussed. The present second article gathers the evidence of long-term pathologic effects caused by early-experienced pain and stress in animal models and humans. Finally, the potentially pain-evoking pre- and perinatal interventions are evaluated, as well as the analgetic/anesthetic methods that can be applied to intrauterine fetuses in everyday obstetrical practice.
人类胎儿在围产期甚至在子宫内生活期间可能会遭受几种可能带来疼痛的干预措施。在过去几年中,关于胎儿疼痛的存在及其缓解必要性的科学争议不断扩大,引发了一场激烈的社会、政治、宗教、道德和哲学辩论,主要聚焦于人工流产期间胎儿所经历的痛苦。在我们这两篇相关论文中,对文献中有关胎儿疼痛的医学科学知识进行了综述。在发表于《匈牙利医学周报》第150卷第11期的第一篇文章中,我们定义了疼痛以及参与主观疼痛感知的神经解剖结构,还有这些结构的发育情况。然后,讨论了有害刺激引发的子宫内应激反应的客观指标(如胎儿神经内分泌、心血管、反射和行为反应)。当前的第二篇文章收集了动物模型和人类中早期经历的疼痛和应激所导致的长期病理影响的证据。最后,评估了可能引发疼痛的产前和围产期干预措施,以及在日常产科实践中可应用于子宫内胎儿的镇痛/麻醉方法。